Most helpful customer reviews
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderful production of Wilde's famous comedy., July 31 2006
This 1952 version of the Oscar Wilde classic romantic is as good to watch today as it ever was. Michael Redgrave stars as Ernest Worthing, (whose name, in fact, is really John), a man who, as a baby, had been found in a bag in the cloakroom at Victoria Station. The story is a comedy of errors and confusions around names, in particular the name Ernest. Mr Worthing wants to marry Gwendoline, daughter of the formidable Lady Bracknell. He dare not tell his beloved that his name is not really Ernest as she has expressed a desire only to wed a man of that name. Gwendoline's cousin, Algernon, is pursuing Mr Worthing's ward, Cecily, but she does not know his real name, she believes he is called Ernest. The comedy starts when Cecily and Gwendoline meet for the first time and realise they are both betrothed to 'Ernest Worthington'. The film stars Margaret Rutherford as Miss Prism and Dame Edith Evans as the snobbish Lady Bracknell. Both actresses play their roles extremely well, as you would expect from such grand dames of the stage.
There are a few extras on this DVD (region 2 version) which include a profile of 'The Importance of Being Earnest', a 'behind the scenes' gallery, a theatrical trailer and biographies of the main actors and the director. The picture is crystal clear and the colours bright. Sound quality is good and there are subtitles for the hard of hearing. All in all, a very good version of one of Wilde's best known and loved works.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Importance Of A Good Commentary!!, Feb 4 2004
Comparing the 1952 film adaptation of The Importance of Being Earnest with the 2002 is problematic, and in many ways, futile. Both films are marvelous and perfect representatives of the acting/film styles of their respective time periods. The 1952 version is structured like a play; the action even begins and ends with a curtain, as if the viewer were in an upper box of a grand theatre or opera house. Similarly, the acting is quite stagy; viewers who prefer their actors to perform their parts in the cinema the same way they would perform them on stage will most likely enjoy this version. In particular, Dame Edith Evans as Lady Bracknell is the epitome of the stage Grand Damme, the empress of her sex, aloof, imperious, cascading from a great height, and perfectly marvelous. Dorothy Tutin as Cecily and Moliere translator Miles Malleson as Rev Chausible are also standouts in their respective roles. The little-known Michael Dennison is an unexpected pleasure as Algernon, complete with ever-present roguish grin, while Joan Greenwood is very pretty but almost a little too stagy to be an effective Gwendolyn. Both Margaret Rutherford as Miss Prism and Michael Redgrave as John Worthing are somewhat miscast; sure, they are dazzling talents, but each is too thoroughly grounded and earthy for the roles they play, particularly Miss Rutherford, who was perhaps the definitive Madame Arcati in Noel Coward's classic Blithe Spirit, filmed only a few years earlier. Still, all the actors are quite effective in their roles; the problem with this DVD lies with the presentation itself: There is no commentary. Of course, director Anthony Asquith is long gone (he died in 1968), but Criterion could and should have called on a film historian, or better yet, a member of the directors own family could have supplied an excellent commentary. Helena Bonham-Carter is not only a luminous actress, she is also Asquith's grand-niece, and it would have been nice to have approached her about the possibility of providing a commentary in this case; a current actresses thoughts and views of how this classic was presented two generations ago would have been priceless. Still, this is an excellent DVD, and a worthwhile film adaptation to add to your collection, especially if you are willing to provide your own running commentary.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
One of the funniest plays ever and one of the best casts, Dec 12 2003
This 1952 Technicolor film classic bring together one of all-time funniest plays in the history of the English language with a dream cast featuring Michael Redgrave, Edith Evans, Joan Greenwood, Margaret Rutherford and Miles Malleson.This film is beautifully mounted; superb direction by Anthony Asquith and terrific color photography by Desmond Dickinson. The Oscar Wilde Victorian comedy is a laugh-a-second series of absolute silliest situations. If you enjoy Classic British Cinema, a brilliant play or any of the above actors, this wonderful DVD MUST be part of your collection. As usual, the quality is typically the best non-restored quality people have come to expect from Criterion. Only the lack of a commentary track or a documentary on the making of this priceless film is lacking.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most recent customer reviews
|