5 of 6 people found the following review helpful
on July 19, 2011
I wasn't sure what to expect when I began Irshad Manji's "Allah, LIberty & Love," although I knew that her career as a public speaker was controversial because of her unconventional views on current issues facing Muslims in North America. Initially, the book seemed to be a collection of tweets and email chats with critics and supporters. Not being a fan of this form of communication, I wasn't entirely impressed. However, considering the number of young Muslims in the west attracted to the fundamentalist version of Islam found on numerous websites, I can understand why she might want to use some of the conventions of social media to provide an alternative interpretation of Islamic beliefs and encourage a dialogue among believers on what it means to be a Muslim in the world today.
However, Manji's intended readership is not limited to her fellow Muslims -- she also takes aim at good, well-meaning people in the west who are afraid to criticize the extremist voices within Islam for fear of being taken as intolerant. She makes the point that it was only through the moral courage of people like Martin Luther King (and she might have mentioned Gandhi and Mandela)that real societal change can take place. But it is the statement of a Muslim colleague of Gandhi, Abdul Ghaffar Khan, that "true freedom comes from disciplining the self, not others" that contains the core of her message to Muslims and non-Muslims alike. That, and her assertion that Islam (and other religions) need to shed the cultural baggage that hides the true message of their holy scriptures. While some may be put off by her "in your face" approach, the issues she brings up are too important to be ignored. Unlike many books on Islam today, Manji's work doesn't dwell on the differences between various groups within the faith, but rather the importance for today's Muslims to become part of a true Islamic reformation, based on the Qur'an's vision of Allah as "the compassionate and merciful."
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful
on October 7, 2011
I can't help but admire Irshad Manji. Despite regularly suffering all the slings, arrows and insults (often personal and obscene) that pass for dialogue in the internet age she never fails to respond with respect, thoughtfulness and in a manner that furthers her argument in a constructive way. Even the most vulgar missives are answered politely, without condescension and on topic. How many bloggers, twitterers and social commentators of all makes and styles are there that could benefit by following her example? More than I can count.
Isharad's book seems to continue her quest of reforming Islam with an emphasis on coaxing mainstream Muslims into wresting their faith from extremists, who she calls "Islamo-tribalists" but on a closer look it is broader than that. She draws liberally on the wisdom and examples of ideological leaders such as Robert Kennedy, Ghandi, Martin Luther King Jr. and even little known Muslims that fit the mould such as Abdul Ghaffer Khan. In so doing she builds universality. Anyone combating oppression, fighting intolerance or even simply seeking to live with reverence and integrity will find something to learn from her book. A book that is both absorbing and inspiring,
0 of 2 people found the following review helpful
on August 6, 2012
With the advent of the printing press, we have to suffer with so called authors. This lady , forget the non content, has such a dry way to write. It makes me sick to read comments , as: "Manji's intended readership is not limited to her fellow Muslims -- she also takes aim at good, well-meaning people in the west who are afraid to criticize the extremist voices within Islam for fear of being taken as intolerant. She makes the point that it was only through the moral courage of people like Martin Luther King.." for Pete's sake, "Martin Luther King" along side manji? I feel my stomach turning. The book is a total waste of time. She has no erudition, she is clumsy in her thinking process and with chapter titles as, Identity can trap and integrity can free or something like that. What a waste of money and time. If you want to waste your money and time buying a mixed up "self-help contorted with twisted ideas" , be my quest. Horrible.
0 of 3 people found the following review helpful
on September 8, 2012
As an individual who aims to enhance his outlook on various cultures, groups, religions, and ways of thinking I have found this book not only untrue, but totally fallacious, bizarre, and nonsensical. The writer of this book is clearly a disturbed and ignorant individual that would much rather express her inner narcissism than present anything of relevance. I would definitely NOT recommend this piece of trash to anyone. It is totally disturbing and outright fallacious. If anyone wants to learn about Islam and Muslims, this is definitely NOT the book to read.