march boutiques-francophones SmartSaver Furniture Introducing Kindle Oasis Music Deals Store sports Tools Family

Customer Reviews

4.2 out of 5 stars86
4.2 out of 5 stars
Format: Hardcover|Change
Price:$20.41+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

This book begins with the classic tale of David versus Goliath. Traditionally interpreted as courage triumphing over great odds, Gladwell shows that this actually wasn't the case. Instead, it was in all likelihood Goliath who was in trouble. As anyone who's played Total War games knows, archers beat infantry and David was an archer with his sling. If he missed, he could just outrun Goliath, turn around and shoot again. Rinse and repeat until Goliath is dead. The huge, mighty, fearsome fighter Goliath was deadly, but there as a limit to his power. Which is essentially the theme of this book. Power, and in particular negative power, has limitations.

In particular Gladwell dwells on the counter-intuitive "inverted U" that underlies a lot of relationships. For example, adding punishment decreases crime, but is there a point at which applying too much punishment increases crime? Or being bombed is bad, but being nearly bombed can actually bolster one's moral as you realize you can survive something awful. Having smaller classes is good, but at some point smaller classes become worse for education. Going to an Ivy league school is good for some, but many more would benefit from not going to a top-level school. Gladwell also discusses how difficulties and challenges generate opportunities for some individuals to flourish. The harsh reality of losing a parent makes a minority of children even stronger, or at least more successful, than if they had never lost a parent.

This counter-intuitive kind of thinking is classic Gladwell, and it makes for an interesting yet informative read. There are a couple of issues I have with the book. First, there's more anecdotes and less science than in his previous books. Second, while he mentions it, he generally glosses over the reality that for most children, hardships cause more harm than good. Even if some diamonds emerge from that pressure, it's a costly path to success (which is why it can generate tough survivors who flourish later in life). For every business tycoon who comes from a rough start, there's a whole lot more kids who weren't able to get past that rough start and end up staying in rough shape for life. Those issues aside, this remains a good book. It's well-written and easy to get through. There are some footnotes that get in the way, and there's actually quite a lot of good information in the appendixes that I wish made it into the text. But it's up to the reader how much they want to pay attention to these items, so they don't necessarily take away from the reading experience. There's a lot of interesting lessons to take away from this book. Perhaps my favorite one is how to successfully coach a "different" basketball team. When I read about it, it immediately struck me as obvious in hindsight, but again, that's the joy of this book and Gladwell in particular. Making the hidden obvious is his specialty, which makes it obvious to me that this is a good book worth recommending. 4 to 4.5 stars out of 5.
0Comment|29 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
I always look forward to a new book by Malcolm Gladwell; he consistently provides readers with awe-inspiring stories, profound insights and provocative ideas. Though some chapters piqued my interest more than others, overall "David and Goliath" successfully engages with its meditations on the archetypal battle between underdogs and top dogs.

Gladwell begins with a recap of the legendary tale of David and Golliath, introducing his main theme: some perceived disadvantages have unsung advantages while perceived advantages encompass overlooked disadvantages. An early chapter about a gritty middle school girl's basketball team contains intimations of a self-help manual but, when the author moves to an explanation of why being a being a big fish in a small pond predicts high achievement better than being a little fish in a big pond, it becomes clear that Gladwell's interest extends beyond simple templates for success.

The book probes into the nature of the underdog and tells the stories of fascinating and amazingly accomplished people: lawyer David Boies, IKEA founder Ingvar Kamprad and leukaemia researcher Jay Freireich to name a few. It shows that stereotypical handicaps like learning disabilities and deprived childhoods can require a person to adapt to the world in ways that later give him/her the upper hand in professional life. Contrarily, those who have sailed through childhood enjoying every good fortune often become less well-equipped to deal with life’s inevitable challenges.
0Comment|11 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on August 19, 2014
I'm a big fan of Malcolm Gladwell and his way of digging deeper into the data to find correlations so many of us miss. This book shows us how bigger is not always better, esp. if you have an opponent who's smart enough to detect your weaknesses. The Bible story of David & Goliath is not nearly as impressive when Gladwell explains how warfare worked back then, and you realize that it was customary for the missile-slingers to go after the heavily-armoured and armed soldiers like Goliath. There's another great chapter on how getting in the best school isn't always best for the student; and how the inverted U-curve demonstrates that there's point where classroom sizes are too small, and where they're too large; kids are best served in the classrooms in-between, regardless of how fancy and financed the "better" schools with much smaller classrooms are.

I never get tired of Malcolm Gladwell.
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on February 5, 2014
Gladwell is an excellent writer and this book is no exception. Thought provoking, entertaining and challenging based on an interesting theory about why some people can overcome what seem to be insurmountable odds which actually train them to develop skills and attitudes which make them great. I love the graphs which depict why smaller class sizes can actually reach a point where they become less functional for inspiring children to succeed.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on December 8, 2013
The book presented interesting anecdotal ideas but I was left wanting more details on how to apply the ideas. As well, the book mostly lacked data evidence for the ideas presented.

For the price of the book, I wanted a bit more. In particular, how often does David defeat Goliath in the real (modern) world?
0Comment|2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on December 30, 2013
There is nothing worse than seeing a live performance of your favorite recording artist and sensing that the magic is in the past.

This book's premise could have been fully explored in a 30 page article. I believe that Mr. Gladwell needed to write this book to fulfill contractual obligations rather than because he was overly inspired by the subject matter. It happens.

It was not tightly written nor particularly well reasoned. There was much repetition, seemingly to fill space. It reads like a second draft.

I loved Outliers and was therefore hoping that the thesis articulated in the story of David and Goliath would be deeply and richly explored. I was disappointed and half way through, I considered putting it down. I didn't; hoping that my trust in the author would be redeemed. Not this time.
0Comment|10 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on December 28, 2013
An easy read, well written, but somehow vacant. As I read elsewhere, Gladwell probably underestimates the entrenched Goliaths of the world -- if you had a choice to be David or Goliath, most of us wouldn't pick the underdog.
0Comment|2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
This latest literary offering of Gladwell challenges the reader to take a second look at situations before accepting the inevitable. Counter-intuitiveness or going against the norm is the guiding principle proclaimed in this collection of personal testimonies about people who dared to think outside the box in typical David vs. Goliath situations. When facing a dire health issue, or an infinitely stronger opponent, or a lack of resources to stave off disaster, or just plain down on one's luck there is a natural tendency for many of us to flee rather than fight and overcome. To challenge that disposition of cowardly despair in the midst of impossible odds, Gladwell has us revisit the biblical tale of David and Goliath on a couple of different levels. Each one points out that fear of an opponent or obstacle is often baseless when seen in the light of reality and relativeness. Goliath, as that indomitable giant, really was a weakling ready to be knocked down to size through the ingenious resourcefulness of a shepherd boy trusting in his sling and God. Everything about this story goes against conventional thinking, which is where Gladwell believes more of us should find ourselves when in trouble: turning a problem into a solution by going where no-one else has gone before. In the subsequent chapters, the reader is introduced to a photographer, a cancer specialist, a lawyer, and a human-rights activist who overcame daunting challenges - some personal, others environmental - by learning to stand up to seemingly impossible odds. Each had to overcome a fear that they would be defeated in their quest to overcome a learning disability, or a violent temper, or limited support for a cause. As Gladwell shows, big and powerful does not always win the day. These stories are inspirational in how they follow through to that moment of triumph when an unique strategy turns the problem on its head and makes believers out of skeptics. Timing and creativity are everything when it comes to making a little bit of sustaining love overcome a whole pile of destructive power.
0Comment|5 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
TOP 500 REVIEWERon September 8, 2014
Gladwell is an easy to read author, and very thoughtful about life in the book. It enables the reader to challenge the standard conceptions that dominate life in a very interesting way. As I found success in my life I knew that there was more to my attitude than just being curious and detail oriented. Gladwell educates uses stories to help the the reader to understand the basis of causality and suggest a new viewpoint on assessing situations. This is a great read!
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on January 23, 2014
If you area fan of Malcolm Gladwell books, this latest one won't disappoint you. As I am on the road a lot, I prefer audiobooks - David & Goliath is a very interesting one to listen to and a good companion for long distance trips.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse