5.0 out of 5 stars Fantastic
Laurie King has written another great book as a prequel to her Justice Hall novel. I get something new out of it every time I read it.
Published on Sep 28 2009 by P. Palmer
3.0 out of 5 stars Historical travel book or mystery?
Although the 5th book in the series, O Jerusalem takes place during the Russell and Holmes' forced departure from England during the adventure of The Beekeeper's Apprentice. King's research and attention to detail is on full display here, perhaps too much detail. An assassination plot in Palestine is the central mystery here, but the story takes too long to unfold. While...
Published on Aug 29 2001 by J. Carroll
Most Helpful First | Newest First
5.0 out of 5 stars Fantastic,
5.0 out of 5 stars first-rate character development,
This review is from: O Jerusalem (Paperback)King's brilliant character development in 'O Jerusalem' is first-rate. Russell and Holmes are tested by their two shadowy companions, and not one of the four are happy with the arrangement. Holmes is rougher then I've know him to be in this previous Russell novels and all four evolve throughout the story in a very realistic and nature way in this dangerous "spy thriller".
5.0 out of 5 stars O Jerusalem- Different but still great,
By A Customer
This review is from: O Jerusalem (Hardcover)I have been into the Mary Russell series for a few years, and this book has been one of my favorite books ever since. Although O Jerusalem has a slower pace than The Beekeeper's Apprentice, it still manages to capture the flavor of the Mary Russell series while incorperating a lot of the Middle Eastern culture. It begins with Mary and Holmes escaping from a deadly enemy back in England. Holmes' brother, Mycroft, suggests a few places for them to go, and they end up landing in Palestine. Their guides, Ali and Mahmoud, lead them through deserts, villages, and wadis as they look for the answer to the mystery. What started as a simple murder evolves into a complex mystery involving salt smugglers, bombs, and the famous Dome Rock. It (the mystery) is based on the precarious balence between the different religions living together in the Holy Land, each doubting the other.
What makes this book stand out is the amount of history and culture included, much more than The Beekeeper's Apprentice had. I would say Laurie King chose to focus more on the culture rather than the plot or character developement, because it seems to me that the plot is a bit difficult, and the character's personalities aren't as well described as in The Beekeeper's Apprentice. However, I believe that too is a part of how the Middle East is potrayed to the outside world- in other words, a bit mysteriously. In any case, I think this is one of the best books so far in the series, and it is definitely worth giving a try.
5.0 out of 5 stars Best since The Beekeeper's Apprentice,
The testing that Russell and Holmes go through in this book make the changes in the characters when they return to London in the first book realistic. I admire the writing craft as true to the individual plot and true to the development of the characters during the series. I'd love to sit down and talk to the author about this book.
2.0 out of 5 stars Uneven Holmes pastiche,
Here, though, the premise isn't that fun. For mysterious reasons (apparently regarding the end of The Beekeeper's Apprentice, which I don't remember very well) Holmes and his young friend Mary Russell are thrown ashore in Palestine ca. 1919, courtesy of Sherlock Holmes' brother Mycroft. They immediately hook up with a couple of mysterious local Arabs, who guide them about the country aimlessly, after making clear how useless they think Holmes and Russell are. It takes several hundred pages before things actually get going.
The difficulty is that this really isn't a detective novel: instead, it's a spy novel, and a slow-moving one at that. It's 300 pages or so before the plot actually takes shape and we know what Holmes and Russell are looking for. It's slow and not very suspenseful, and it takes so long to get going that by the time it does, we don't care what's going on. I have to confess that while some of the characters were interesting, the plot was so moribund that I wasn't that impressed. I wouldn't recommend this book to anyone other than Holmes fanatics.
4.0 out of 5 stars Sherlock holmes adventures from a woman's point of view,
By A Customer
This review is from: O Jerusalem (Hardcover)O'Jerusalem by LAUIRE R.King Is a personal accounts of Sherlock Homels case written by his young partner Mary Russell.The plot is interging,devloping over the course of the noverl.This as a result can be a little tiresome. Tet don't the descriptive nature of which King has prepaired for you.
I found the historical content to be quite interesting and how the two Protagonist lived in the Middle East.I also found the quotes at the beginning of the chapter to be words of wisdom that I may use today.I suggest that the leader should catch up on all of Sherlock Holmes adventures and possibly include some with Mary Russel.
The book is very unique and insightful about the famous inhabitant of 221B Bakerstreet.
4.0 out of 5 stars Evocatively written, but difficult to get into,
That said, "Jerusalem" is not necessarily the sequel to the previous work ("The Moor") in the way that "The Moor" was the sequel to "A Letter of Mary".
As a result, the reader needs to remember that Mary Russell is now 19 again and most decidedly not married to Holmes. While there are certain overtones in the book implying that it was in Palestine that Russell realised whatever feelings she had for her partner-in-sleuthing, King does not dwell on any romantic implications.
The scene is Palestine at the end of the First World War. The collapse of the Ottoman Empire from within has resulted in the attempts by many of its former constituent parts to declare independence. In all of this, Palestine is governed by General Robert Allenby and his officers.
One of the main themes of this novel is the growing trust between the Hazrs and Mary Russell. King phrases this, in parts, as being almost a feminist victory in what was then (and is now) a strongly male-dominated society. Mary's skill at dagger-throwing, for example, becomes a great asset to her in a memorable scene set in a remote village.
Another important theme is that of Mary's Judaism. King devotes many passages to the emotions brought about by Mary's entrance into Jerusalem, seeing the fortress of Masada and swimming in the Dead Sea. Indeed, much of "O Jerusalem" verges on a travelogue of the area.
Finally, there is also the contrast between the simple Bedu existence of Ali and Mahmoud and the transplanted English society of Allenby's men and the people of Jerusalem. King clearly relishes the irony in these differences and communicates this relish well.
You may have noticed that there has not been any mention of plot as yet. This is because the plot itself is secondary to the character development and - one imagines - Ms King's demonstration that she can be a serious writer if the mood takes her. To be sure, her descriptions of things ranging from turn-of-the-century Jerusalem to Bedu society are right on the money, but the "Sherlock Holmes in Palestine" part of the plot is a hastily-assembled business dealing with espionage with vague political overtones. It never really gets adequately explained, but it serves as a great excuse to wander four well-written characters around one of the most mystical settings a writer could ever find.
In the final analysis, this is one of those books you'll either love or hate. Don't read it expecting the customary "Holmes deduces the most obscure facts" ending, because such deduction as appears here (the location of a particular monastery) doesn't appear to have a great bearing on the end result. Read it instead as an evocative account of the Middle East after the First World War and you'll probably get more out of it.
My recommendation is that the reader try to get their hands on a copy of "Justice Hall" as rapidly as possible after reading this book. King makes the point in her foreword that the two books are connected, and the connection is much stronger when they are read back-to-back.
2.0 out of 5 stars Desert story leaves the reader with a terrible thirst!,
Unfortunately, the excellent descriptive elements of the narrative are wasted due primarily to the creeping paralysis of modern social views that take over the story from time to time. The book strays a bit too often into the desert of political correctness, if not blatant feminism (why, *naturally* a nineteen year old girl can be the intellectual equal of Sherlock Holmes, beat up a man twice her size, properly enlighten Arabs on respecting women, etc.).
Perhaps it is simply the author's personal need to speak out about the injustices of past history and lierature in the only way that she felt was open to her. While a noble cause (albeit somewhat misguided), I'd much prefer it be done on her own time and not on the time of those who enjoy a good Holmes story.
Even if the reader is not nettled by the "enlightning" of characters set a century in the past, there are still other problems with the book. For example, the main character (Russell of course, not Holmes), seems drawn to prattling about her religion (another personal stake for the author?). Doesn't seem to fit a Holmes story, but that isn't what we really have with "O Jerusalem" anyway.
The banner at the top of the paperback's cover reads: "A novel of suspense featuring Mary Russell and her partner Sherlock Holmes" (HER partner?! Holmes a second-stringer?!). Clearly this implies that Russell, not Holmes, is the star of the story (and she is), so why bother with Holmes at all? Why not just introduce the character and let her grow on her own as a 1920's detective? If the author desires to create a character such as Mary Russell, why not just do so?
The answer is that what we have here is yet another writer attempting to graft their own, new characters into the already well-established world of Holmes, both for support as well as marketing. After all, unless an author has name value (such as a Stephen King or John Grisham), chances are a reader will purchase a new book with an established character like Holmes rather than take a chance on a new series with an unknown lead like Russell.
If the new character being introduced has any worth at all (as the Russell character seems to have), then it should be able to stand on its own without the crutch of Holmes to support it. The fact that the author chose to tack on to her series the immortal name of Sherlock Holmes speaks more of a lack of faith in her new character rather than an honest desire to expand upon the world founded by Doyle.
Compare this series to the excellent work of Quinn Fawcett and his Mycroft Holmes books, and you'll see what I mean. Fawcett obviously respects the characters as offered by Doyle, in the world offered by Doyle. He expands upon them in a proper and fitting way, while at the same time introducing his new characters into the story. At no time do any modern, pet personal causes of the author take over the narrative, and so there are no distractions from the late Victorian setting of the story.
The pity is that Ms. King has a great talent for description and action that fits nicely with the style of Doyle. If only Ms. King would undertake to write a straight, old-fashioned Holmes/Watson mystery, rather than bowdlerizing the works of Doyle with modern viewpoints and characters, the Holmes audience would be much better served.
4.0 out of 5 stars vivid, imaginative, well worth reading,
5.0 out of 5 stars I Don't Care What Others Say: I Loved It!,
I simply loved the way Laurie R. King (and because of this, Russell) really and truly understood and recognized these people as who they are and what they are, not trying to hide or disguise it at all. It is refreshing, truly.
This fine piece of work was wrought well by the master story-teller Laurie R. King, and is sure to delight you. Just as Russell had to show she was competent to Holmes, so she does now once again, this time to two Arab males that believe women to be inferior to everything else in the world, especially them. It is comic yet heart-wrenching, serious yet light. A hard thing to explain, true...but if you read the book, you will understand.
Most Helpful First | Newest First
O Jerusalem by Laurie R. King (Paperback - April 28 2009)
CDN$ 18.95 CDN$ 13.68