Customer Reviews


22 Reviews
5 star:
 (11)
4 star:
 (5)
3 star:
 (2)
2 star:
 (3)
1 star:
 (1)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 

The most helpful favourable review
The most helpful critical review


5.0 out of 5 stars Not What Is Was Hoping For, But Still Was Great
I love Amanda Quick's books, but this one didn't seem to have the sparkle and shine of previous books. To me, it didn't grab me by the collar and yank me into the plot. It still enjoyed it, but I found some things wrong with the plot. 1) The mystery was all over the place. It seemed like Ms. Quick just spontaneously thought things up and decided to stick them in...
Published on May 26 2000 by Kelly

versus
3.0 out of 5 stars Mischief versus Deceptions
I had read one Amanda Quick story which was Deceptions and I enjoyed it so I thought I would get another to read.I might have been unfortunate to find the only other book in her collection which was almost the same story.
The heroines had the same*blue stocking* personalities,both raised by unconventional people.Both had written articles on antiquities and did not...
Published on April 25 2004


‹ Previous | 1 2 3 | Next ›
Most Helpful First | Newest First

3.0 out of 5 stars Mischief versus Deceptions, April 25 2004
By A Customer
Ce commentaire est de: Mischief (Paperback)
I had read one Amanda Quick story which was Deceptions and I enjoyed it so I thought I would get another to read.I might have been unfortunate to find the only other book in her collection which was almost the same story.
The heroines had the same*blue stocking* personalities,both raised by unconventional people.Both had written articles on antiquities and did not care for their reputations.Cold blooded Colchester is almost the same character as the the hero in Deceptions who lacks the Flamecrest fire.Both heroines talk about emotion and passion with logic and not feeling.
Both books have ancient languages that need to be translated.Plus a focus on ancient matriomonial customs ,,,,,,,I started to really wonder if this was the same book.There are also a pair of lesbian lovers thrown in to the equation which has turned up yet again in a third book by the same author, (Seduction).By now I was wondering if I was reading the same story.The heroes both have mortal enemies who can be persuaded to become amenable.The heroine is being pursued for her ancient treasure in both books.Overall I found 25 similarities between the two books,by that point I gave up counting.Reading Mischief on it's own would be best.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


3.0 out of 5 stars Skip the love scenes.. (unless you want to giggle), Sept. 14 2001
By 
Shinjinee Sen (Bethesda MD USA) - See all my reviews
Ce commentaire est de: Mischief (Paperback)
I first discovered Amanda Quick some years back, well before I discovered Signet Regencies and most other Regency historicals. I enjoyed some of her early books, but was under no illusions that her books were particularly representative of Regency society or the typical Regency woman. In some senses, a new author Julia Quinn reminds me of Amanda Quick, except that Quinn's writing and plotting has been improving slowly in a relatively career. It is hard to say whether Quick has peaked as a writer, since I do not read her works under other names. Among her books, I most enjoyed SCANDAL (not a typical Quick), DESIRE (not typical either, being a raucously funny ahistorical medieval), and SURRENDER (where the story certainly takes an untypical turn). I picked up the audio tape of MISCHIEF, partly as a way to get through this book and to try audio book versions of authors while I walked or did errands about the house.
Warning: Firstly, romances can sound very different when read aloud than when a reader reads a print version. In the audio version, the skill of the narrator is all-important. My version (not the one available at Amazon) was narrated by Barbara Rosenblat who is excellent at rendering voices and accents. No problems there. The set consisted of 9 tapes, and was unabridged.
Now the problems begin. Firstly, since I listen slower (and more inattentively) than I read, it did not take much time before I spotted the villain, or the principal villain anyway. What I could not figure out is why this was not obvious to Imogen and Matthias. Secondly, Imogen sounds pretty irritating, and her breathiness comes through all too unfortunately. By comparison, Clare (DESIRE), Emily (SCANDAL) and Victoria (SURRENDER) were definitely not irritating, even though Emily also used swear words liberally. Thirdly, I was hard put not to laugh through the lovemaking scenes. I had never previously thought of Quick writing purple prose, but those descriptions certainly fitted that description. Let me say that I did not linger over *those* scenes.
Now about the plot. The hero is an enthusiast of ancient Zamar (a civilization constructed by Quick) and an amateur archaeologist who is estranged from his father and the rest of his family. He meets the heroine, because of a promise made to her late uncle. The heroine, it turns out, is not only enthusiastic about ancient Zamar, but she is, well, enthusiastic about almost everything else, including investigation of a friend's mysterious death. In the process, she acts somewhat recklessly. Furthermore, the heroine (Imogen) thinks of the hero (Matthias) as a person with "weak nerves", and persists in this self-delusion although everyone else clearly knows differently. It is a mystery how Imogen and her aunt have the kind of access to high society that permits them to be suitable chaperone for Patricia (Matthias's half-sister) who is an earl's daughter - especially considering that they reside in a house that has been rented in the past by shady characters, to say the least. But Quick is not known for internal consistency within plots.
Patricia is another breathless young woman, whose rudeness to her erstwhile chaperones and general credulity took my breath away. Her relations with Matthias are sketched lightly, in part because the story concentrates on the romance between Imogen and Matthias.
The most interesting part of the story was ancient Zamar, and Matthias and Imogen's involvement with that long-vanished civilization, not to mention the society fad with all things Zamarian. The rest of the story was weak, with the murder mystery being ho-hum. One of the weak points was the credulity of high society regarding a certain titled person; one would assume that society had neither heard of peerage reference works or of the House of Lords. The involvement of this person in the story rather strained my belief in the solution of the murders.
For the story as a whole
Heroine = 2 stars (very irritating)
Hero = 4.5 stars (rather interesting childhood and youth; unorthodox interests and attitudes)
Secondary characters = 3.8 stars (some interesting characters; irritating sister and housekeeper)
Romance = 3.5 stars (competent, but not engrossing)
Mystery = 3.1 stars (villain guessed almost at outset; motives and methods made little sense)
Bedroom scenes = 2 stars (irritating, and made me want to laugh)
Overall rating = 3.2 stars.
This is not a Quick I would recommend to most people; even Quick devotees will be somewhat disappointed. I would advise them, instead to read SURRENDER or one of the other Quick novels written before 1995.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars Not What Is Was Hoping For, But Still Was Great, May 26 2000
Ce commentaire est de: Mischief (Paperback)
I love Amanda Quick's books, but this one didn't seem to have the sparkle and shine of previous books. To me, it didn't grab me by the collar and yank me into the plot. It still enjoyed it, but I found some things wrong with the plot. 1) The mystery was all over the place. It seemed like Ms. Quick just spontaneously thought things up and decided to stick them in. It was almost as if she didn't know who she wanted her bad guy to be until the last couple pages and then added them in hurridly. 2) The side characters didn't make me feel for them. I usually adore the side characters and plots in Ms. Quick's books, but the other people in *Mischief* didn't make me feel for them. I wanted more of an explanation for the relationship between Hugo and Patricia. They kind of faded off at the end, and I was left with some questions. 3) I'm back to the mystery again. It reasolved too close to the end. In other Quick books, there is still some time with the characters even after they found out who the bad guy was. In *Mischief* there were only about ten pages left after the murderer was discovered.
But there are a lot of reasons why I did like it, and I felt that it really did deserve five stars. 1) I could really identify with Imogen. I loved that she was often clumsy, as that is a trait that I suffer from (don't we all?). Her love of ancient things also sped the plot along when there were parts that it might start to drag. 2) Mathias was unusual and delightful. He let Imogen do what she wanted to do and didn't usual restrict her from being herself. He also kept up her illusion that he had weak nerves which was cute. 3) Zamar. I loved it! It was nice to have a legend be the common ground that tied Imogen and Mathias together. I loved reading about it, and I hope Ms. Quick incorperates it into her next books. *Mischeif* does have it's faults, but hey, that's what keeps authors humble. If they write fantastic peices all the time (although *Mischeif* was pretty darn close to perfect) they don't have any constructful comments to work off of. All in all, *Mischeif* is a great, light hearted love story that is highly recomended to any romance or Amanda Quick fan.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars Amanda Quick�s most engaging book!, May 17 2000
Ce commentaire est de: Mischief (Paperback)
I'm an avid Amanda Quick reader and usually can finish her books in two days while still functioning in life and doing the usual mundane day-to-day things. Such was not the case with _Mischief_, I absolutely *could not* put this book down -- I finished it in one day. Not only are the characters amazing, the plot moved along at such a wonderfully fast pace that I didn't even realize time was passing. I became absorbed in the story -- it was like a was watching a movie. The characters and scenery are so vivid that I felt like I was part of the story. It was as if I was peering over the shoulders of the main characters and experiencing the action right along with them. As always, Ms. Quick created characters that are captivating and dazzling. Matthias is dangerous, dark and mysterious. There is an air about him that is fascinating. He is the very picture of a heart-stopping hero. Imogen is charmingly clumsy. She is headstrong and unconcerned what Society thinks. Watching these two together was not only enchanting but intoxicating. They have an outstanding chemistry that bursts into life whenever they're together. I loved the way that Imogen always insisted upon leading whenever they danced and how it amused and frustrated Matthias. Also, Imogen's insistence that Matthias has delicate sensibilities is extremely funny! Unlike most readers, I had no problem with the talk of ancient Zamar. I saw it for what it was -- a plot device designed to move the story along and give the main characters something in common. I found lost Zamar quite interesting and bewitching and adored the added depth it gave to Matthias and Imogen's relationship. The very last scene will touch your heart and bring tears to your eyes! _Mischief_ was an outstanding experience and I highly recommend this book for either the long-time Amanda Quick fan or the first-time reader. _Mischief_ is a choice example of what Amanda Quick does so well.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


4.0 out of 5 stars Good, but not as good, Feb. 5 1998
By A Customer
Ce commentaire est de: Mischief (Paperback)
I am a serious Amanda Quick fan, and the bindings have worn out of my copies of Ravished, Dangerous, Deception, and Scandal. These are the best Romance novels ever written, in my opinion. The story in Mischief is definetly good and entertaining. The problem is, however, that Ms. Quick is sacrificing the details that made her older books so engaging. I am worried that she may never again write characters as loveable as Harriet, Prudence and Olympia. Or as desirable as the Beast of Blackthorn hall, Mr. Chillhurst and the Fallen Angel. What is missing is the insight into the new characters. Since this author writes under 3 names, she turns out a LOT of books. Unfortunately, they are all suffering from the speed. This book needed another 50 pages to flesh it out. The depth was missing. I will be very sad if there are no new Amanda Quick books that I want to read over and over. Please, Amanda, let us know your characters again and care about them. No one creates as fun and sexy a story as you can. Don't make them over so soon.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


4.0 out of 5 stars A fun read, Dec 18 1998
By A Customer
Ce commentaire est de: Mischief (Paperback)
This was a fun read. I especially loved seeing Cold-blooded Colchester take full advantage of Imogen's assumption that he had delicate nerves (once he failed to convince her that her assumption was false). The story was interesting and had a clever plot.
One caveat: I was a bit disappointed that the truth concerning "the big surprise" of the story didn't explode in Imogen's head as soon as it did into mine. (Colchester had an excuse; the set-up of the "surprise" had been given to Imogen by her aunt.) Anyway, by keeping Imogen in the dark long after a careful reader would have figured out the plot surprise, it was a bit insulting to this reader's intelligence. Did Amanda Quick think that it took her readers as long as it took Imogen to find out the final plot twist?
Other than this, Mischief was a highly entertaining and amusing read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars This Book Made Me A Convert, June 22 1998
By A Customer
Ce commentaire est de: Mischief (Paperback)
I don't think I had read a true romance novel ever in my life until I picked up this book. I make a habit of putting bestselling books on hold at the library and reading them as they become available. Picking up this book, I was surprised to find a romance. I figured I'd give it a shot, but was sure that I would not finish the first chapter before I pronounced it trash. I think I read this book in one day. I literally could not put it down, and I'm sure I got about 3 hours of sleep that night to finish it. Amanda Quick took me to another world, a great escape that made my stomach flip during the romance scenes. I have no qualms recommending this book as a good place to start for all you "book snobs" who think you won't enjoy anything that doesn't make you struggle intellectually. Live a little! I'm still trying to get my hands on her other books as we speak...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


4.0 out of 5 stars Loyalty and love., July 30 2000
By 
L. S. Tucker (Port St. Lucie, FL USA) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
Ce commentaire est de: Mischief (Paperback)
Imogen Waterstone needed help to destroy the man she believed murdered her best friend, the man who participated in her social ruin. Who better than Matthias Marshall, Earl of Colchester, the man who discovered the lost island of Zamar? Imogen decides that Matthias is not the man of action she assumed he would be, that in fact, he is subject to nerves. No matter what his reputation or what others say about him, Imogen will not believe anything bad about Matthias. Bemused, Colchester finds his match in the strong-willed, unpredictable Imogen.
The thing that most attracts me to Amanda Quick books are the strange and wonderful heroines. They discount anything bad about the hero and, ultimately, lead him like a dangerous panther on a leash. Then there is the witty repartee. Exquisite and delightfully humorous.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1.0 out of 5 stars I failed to see the 'Mystique.', July 6 1998
By 
Bonnie F. Rutledge "Cool Aunt" (Charlotte, NC United States) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
Ce commentaire est de: Mischief (Paperback)
I believe some of Amanda Quick's older works rank among the best in the genre. This selection, however, was tortuously dull. While I admire the attempt to give the story thematic symbolism, the constant references to 'lost Zamar' were only repetative. It was a mantra that inspired no emotional investment in this reader, but rather made finishing the book a chore. Turning each page was a duty, not entertainment. One of the strengths of previous stories has been the unorthodox nature of the heroines, but I found Imogen Waterstone to be distinctly unlikeable, thereby killing the sense of romance for me. I certainly didn't care whether such a rude, senseless character achieved a happy-ever-after. I intend to hold onto my copies of 'Rendezvous' and 'Surrender,' but 'Mystique' felt too much like my very own 'Rutledge Curse.'
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars A fascinating blend of romance and intrigue., July 6 1996
By A Customer
Ce commentaire est de: Mischief (Hardcover)
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. Ms. Quick brings her characters to life and makes the reader wish to join them in their escapades. The plot twists and turns in intricate patterns with humor and romance balancing the effect. Ms. Quick breathes life and a joy of living into her hero and heroine. I believe that she is a master at her craft and should be read by all who enjoy a magnificent romance with a hint of intrigue and mystery to spice it up. This book takes the reader to 18th century England into Polite Society with the added bonus of a fictional newly discovered culture. The mystery of a murder and the antics of the two heroes will ensure the reader is immensely consumed with a desire to read this book to the very end. I highly recommend this book to everyone
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


‹ Previous | 1 2 3 | Next ›
Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Mischief
Mischief by Amanda Quick (Paperback - March 31 1997)
CDN$ 11.99 CDN$ 10.79
In Stock
Add to cart Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews