Auto boutiques-francophones Simple and secure cloud storage Personal Care Cook All-New Kindle Paperwhite Music Deals Store Fall Tools

Customer Reviews

19
4.3 out of 5 stars
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

Showing 1-2 of 2 reviews(3 star)show all reviews
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
on June 27, 2013
Gwyn gives his opinion of events and omits important background. I could give numerous examples but have selected only one.
He describes the Privy Council's rulings in favour of the Provinces after Confederation on constitutional matters as 'quirky'.
In fact the rulings were guided by the arguments of Edward Blake, leader of the Liberal Party after Confederation, the man who would have been our second Prime Minister, had he not resigned the leadership in favour of his lieutenant, Alexander Mackenzie.
The Privy Council was the highest court in Canadian jurisprudence for a very long time; it has now been replaced by the Supreme Court, members of which are appointed by the federal government, which of course does not want interpretations of the BNA Act which favour the Provinces.
In fact it was a Canadian lawyer - a man, who, unlike Gwyn, was Canadian born - Edward Blake, who persuaded the Council in favour of the Provinces. Below is a passage from one of his speeches to it. Blake was perhaps the greatest orator in the English language in our history. Macdonald was afraid of him. He is mentioned only once, briefly, by Gwyn.

Read it and ask yourself: should a decision influenced by such a speech be fairly described as 'quirky'?

Edward Blake to the Privy Council, 1888

"The word federal is the key which unlocks the clauses and reveals their contents. It is the glass that enables us to discern what is written. By its light the Act must be construed. What then was the general scheme of this Act ? First of all, as I suggest, it was to create a federal as distinguished from a legislative union, but a union composed of several existing and continuing entities. It was not the intention of Parliament to mutilate, confound and destroy the provinces mentioned in the preamble, and having from their mangled remains stewed in some legislative cauldron, to evoke by some legislative incantation absolutely new provinces into an absolutely new existence. It was the design, I say, by gentle and considerate terms to preserve the vital breath and continue the political existence of the old provinces. However this may be, they were being made, as has been well said, "not fractions of a unit but units of a multiple". The Dominion is the multiple and each province is a unit."

St.Catherine’s Milling and Lumber Company v. The Queen

Note: The case concerned timber licenses and whether the federal government or the province, in this case Ontario, had jurisdiction. The provinces have jurisdiction and the revenue from the licenses to this day.(I think the quote is from Oliver Mowat. Both Mowat and Blake were Liberal Premiers of Ontario).
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoSending feedback...
Thank you for your feedback.
Sorry, we failed to record your vote. Please try again
Report abuse
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful
on September 4, 2010
A good read. The author is eloquent and even funny at times. The style is clear, concise, and very accessible to everyone.

A colourful character in outlook and style, John A was the antithesis of his British contemporary, Gladstone. Macdonald was a political pragmatist who never failed to use patronage to build a loyal following. A master in finding exception and ways to exploit parliamentary loopholes John A manoeuvred himself skilfully to reach the pinnacle of power.

His pragmatism was matched with an acute political sense of strategy. An avowed anglophile and staunch anti-American, he was not in the least interested in the "vision thing". He was quick to understand from others, however, that a federal union of the British North American colonies was the best way to secure the country's national particularities and ties to Britain. Along with his French alter ego, George-Étienne Cartier, Macdonald has forged a strong alliance between both the English and French sections of the country making the union of the BNA colonies possible.

In acting for the future Macdonald laid out a path for the creation of Canada and made it a viable political entity able to overcome the coming challenges of the next century.

Being myself from the French part of the country I can only deplore how the book is "one-sided", as a previous reviewer judiciously remarked. No mention of French Canadian contribution is ever mentioned among the references (except for one). Having been otherwise it would have given further qualitative content and meaning to the book. A French translation of it could have also been seriously considered and at the same time made a real contribution to the whole of the country instead of remaining Ontario-centric
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoSending feedback...
Thank you for your feedback.
Sorry, we failed to record your vote. Please try again
Report abuse
     
 
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Nation Maker: Sir John A. Macdonald: His Life, Our Times
Nation Maker: Sir John A. Macdonald: His Life, Our Times by Richard J. Gwyn (Paperback - Aug. 21 2012)
CDN$ 17.99

Nation Maker: Sir John A. Macdonald: His Life, Our Times
Nation Maker: Sir John A. Macdonald: His Life, Our Times by Richard J. Gwyn (Hardcover - Sept. 27 2011)
CDN$ 33.39