Most helpful critical review
One of the most moving and tragic of stories ...
on May 18, 2000
A Bridge Too Far, relating the events that lead to the Allied defeat in the Operation Market-Garden, is one of the most poignant and moving books I have the honor to read. It was simply too deep for mere words. As I read accounts ater accounts of the courage and the chivalry displayed by both sides (Allied and German) in the operation, I was both stunned and amazed. I also found the tragedy of war most acutely displayed in this account, as the author notes failures upon failures which ultimately lead to the allied defeat. It was so sad to find that the Allied side so underestimated the German forces, distrusted the Dutch, overlooked basic intelligence, and overall planned and sent men on a ridiculous mission... even a military dilletante like me could see the fallacy of a single tank file over a 80 mile corridor in enemy territory. Just shows that you shoudl enevr ever underestimate your foes.
However, that is not to say this was a wonderful book, more as it accurately and stirringly portrayed all those relevant information into an understandable analysis of the Allied failure. I am much indebted to the author for putting this book into my hands (figuratively speaking). As good as his other book, the Longest Day, and helluva lot better then any 2-3 hr movie could possibly be.