|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
13 Reviews
|
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
|
|
Most Helpful First | Newest First
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
Promising; certainly worth a try,
By
This review is from: Freedom from Fibromyalgia: The 5-Week Program Proven to Conquer Pain (Paperback)
Something's going on here/ But what it is ain't exactly clear --Bob DylanThese lyrics from a few years back pretty much sum up the medical position on fibromyalgia. Selfridge, who is a medical doctor, and Franklynn, who is a professional writer, don't make it any clearer, but they have the considerable merit (especially from the point of view of the fibromyalgia sufferer) of having suffered from the disease themselves. Selfridge advertises herself as "90 percent cured" (p. 23) while Franklynn "feels at least 90 percent improved" (p. 26). Although Selfridge rightly disparages the term "psychosomatic" (p. 40), it is clear that she believes that the proximate cause of fibromyalgia is the effect negative emotions have on the body, particularly the emotions of anger and rage. She believes that the "mind, brain, and body conspire to generate...real physical symptoms" (p. 60). Here's the way the authors lay it out on pages 58-60: "For sensitive people" having grown up "amidst tensions too overwhelming" for their "sensitive nervous system[s]," having been shoved "relentlessly toward the impossible goal of being perfect[,]...a significant loss--of a loved one, a job, status, or income--or a significant emotional shakeup, such as a car accident" can be the event that "may stimulate the production of chemicals that create fibromyalgia symptoms." In short (p. 61), "Fibromyalgia sufferers are more sensitive to stress than the general population." Are they right? Nobody knows for sure. Fibromyalgia, like some other chronic diseases that plague our society--the many kinds of arthritis, chronic fatigue syndrome, myofascial pain syndrome, etc.--may be the result of some as yet unidentified factor of modern life. Most likely they are the result of a combination of factors, creating a mind-body syndrome of illness. Until such time as medical science figures it out, we have to go on living. Can we live without pain? (I use the editorial "we" not because I personally suffer from fibromyalgia, but because someone I love does, and I identify strongly with her suffering.) The authors say we can, and they lay out a five week program. Does it work? I would say that it indeed will work in many cases, not only for sufferers of fibromyalgia, but for sufferers of many other chronic diseases of unclear etiology, perhaps some of those mentioned above. The reason is simple: their prescription includes things as meditation, regular exercise ("becoming a couch potato can aggravate fibromyalgia" p. 232), a positive attitude toward yourself and your place in the world and so on--things we all should be doing as matter of course. I would add that a belief in a power beyond the body and beyond the "ego-I" created by the bioculture would help. Note that, most significantly for fibromyalgia sufferers, it is the management of anger that the authors prescribe. Anger comes from frustration. We are not getting what we want, which is to be loved and appreciated. We want and need to be admired for our good qualities and given some slack for our not-so-good qualities. If it is true, as the authors state, that "Close to 90 percent of known fibromyalgia sufferers are women" (p. 20), we might very well ask why? An answer could be that women especially suffer from a poor self image because of the media propaganda of our society that has devalued those women who are not slim, young, rich, famous, and beautiful. The secret is not to change the society, which is impossible. It is to change our attitude toward society's delusions. As in yoga, it is a process of renunciation: we need to renounce (and really believe it) society's mistaken judgment. We also need to understand "you can't always get what you want" and recognize the negative effect unfulfilled desire can have on ourselves. When I was young and relatively handsome, the girls used to listen to every word I said. Now that I am old and gray, they don't find me so intelligent anymore. What happened to me? Nothing. (I may even have gotten smarter.) What is the cure? Not to care. To understand who and where I am, and to be content with that--indeed to revel in it. The authors include a short chapter on Resources with places to write, Web sites, and books to read including two by Deepak Chopra and three by John E. Sarno, whose The Mindbody Prescription (1998) was obviously part of the inspiration for this book. Incidentally, the reason that the authors and most authorities now reject the term "psychosomatic" is that it has picked up the unfortunate and incorrect sense of "a mental illness" or "an illness caused by mental problems." This is not what the word means; the usage is corrupt; alas, nothing can be done about that. A new word is needed, or better yet, a new understanding, such as presented in this book, that mind affects body; body affects mind, and that an imbalance can lead to illness.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Sounds too good to be true but it works!,
By A Customer
This review is from: Freedom from Fibromyalgia: The 5-Week Program Proven to Conquer Pain (Paperback)
My mother sent me this book, and being a scientist, I was very sceptical. However, I had nothing to lose and decided to follow the program. That was three years ago and I rarely have any clinical signs now. It has convinced me of the health connection between the mind and the body. I hope you have the same success I did.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
A no-nonsense approach that works,
By Cathy Sandoval (Greeley, CO United States) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Freedom from Fibromyalgia: The 5-Week Program Proven to Conquer Pain (Paperback)
As a sufferer of fibromyalgia for the past three years, I looked far and wide to find help. One can find testimonials for miraculous improvement from just about everything from colostrum, animal livers, getting rid of chemicals in fruits and nuts, too much phosphate, too little glycosamine...too many iffy possibilities!!! Finally, I found a book which explains in plain terms how emotions cause the release of certain chemicals into the body and in turn, how these chemicals affect our health. This understanding of the mind/body connection from very measurable indicators has served to help me understand how my pain is triggered, and more importantly, how to control it. It is not fluff, it is NOT blame the victim. On the contrary, by taking control of one's thoughts, lifestyle, and state of mind, one also takes back control of one's life from a very real and very tenacious disease. Thank you, Dr. Selfridge and Mr. Peterson, it has helped a lot. I have shared this book with my Dr. in the hopes that he, too, will find it useful in treating his other suffering patients.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
My patients say this book, "Helps them the most.",
By Iris Weverman (Toronto, Canada) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Freedom from Fibromyalgia: The 5-Week Program Proven to Conquer Pain (Paperback)
My name is Iris Weverman. I am a registered physical therapist in Toronto, Canada. I treat, in my practice, a lot of people with Fibromyalgia, Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and chronic pain. I thoroughly enjoyed your book and my patients come into the office and tell me how they feel about your book. They say of all the books they have read-and they read everything-your book has helped them the most. They say it really makes sense and they have gained a lot of insight into their conditions and themselves from its contents.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Dr. Sarno, in a foreword, calls this "a very important book",
By Janet Roseman (Madison, WI) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Freedom from Fibromyalgia: The 5-Week Program Proven to Conquer Pain (Paperback)
Foreword by Dr. John E. Sarno, Author of The Mindbody Prescription (1998, Warner Books), Mind over Back Pain (William Morrow, 1984) and Healing Back Pain (Warner Books, 1991) I am pleased to introduce this important book to the reading public. We are in the midst of a number of epidemics in the United States that are a direct result of the failure of the North American medical community to recognize the cause of these epidemics. It is as the doctors had suddenly decided that the germ theory of disease was no longer valid. In this case, they have decided that a variety of pain disorders that are clearly based on the interplay of everyday human emotions with physical reactions are due either to some mysterious chemical reaction or physical concomitants, like repetitive stress in the Workplace. One of these disorders is a condition that affects millions of American women that goes by the name of fibromyalgia. This condition has become epidemic in the last fifteen years or so and immediately prompts the question: What has happened to explain this new epidemic? The human race has been around for hundreds of thousands of years. Why is there an epidemic of fibromyalgia now? The answer is simple. Because it is a mind-body disorder that will spread in epidemic fashion if it is not recognized as such, and that is what has happened in the United States. Dr. Selfridge and Mr. Peterson have suffered from this disorder and have recovered from it because they came to know the true nature of the problem. Now they want to share their knowledge of this devastating condition and what they did to get over it. This is a very important book, for there are very few people, in or out of the medical community, who understand what fibromyalgia is all about. Dr. Selfridge and Mr. Peterson are pioneers-and their experience and their advice are both in the tradition of pioneers whose mission is to reveal the truth-and humanitarians, strongly motivated to help those who are in trouble and in need of guidance and help. Not everyone can profit from their message, but there are millions who will. I salute them for their courage and their devotion to the needs of people who suffer the disabling consequences of pain, in this case the pain of fibromyalgia. John Sarno, M.D
4.0 out of 5 stars
Fibromyalgia IS cureable- don't believe your doctor.,
By Helping Hand Hypnosis "David" (HelpingHandHypnosis.com) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Freedom from Fibromyalgia: The 5-Week Program Proven to Conquer Pain (Paperback)
If you are a skeptic, you need to read this book. If you are in chronic pain, you need to read this book. If you have been let down by the medical industry or "milked" by holistic practitioners, you NEED to read this book. I am a practicing Hypnotherapist who has healed himself using Dr.Sarno's methods, many of my Toronto area clients have been helped tremendously by my incorporation of those methods into my practice of pain control and elimination. My personal experience with this book and Dr.Sarno's other books have become the cornerstone for my "Helping Hand Hypnosis" strategy of defeating chronic pain and TMS manifestations such as Tinitus, Carpul Tunnel Syndrome, Tendinitis etc. Everyone experiences some form of mindbody disorder in their life at sometime, be it headache, stomache ache, "nerves", allergies or harmless, transient symptoms like blushing. Until the medical community can explain the mechanics of blushing, don't be so eager to dispell the information in this insightful and marvellous book. Your doctor is missing the picture, as is your chiropractor, physiotherapist etc. DRUGS ARE NOT THE ANSWER!! THis book is!! Buy it, read it again and again. YOU WILL BE PAIN FREE-it just takes understanding and a little effort on your part. Anyone giving this book a poor review is ignorant in the most harmless sense of the word. Everyone I have recommended this book to or seen as a Helping Hand Hypnosis Hypnotherapy client HAS MADE DRAMATIC IMPROVEMENTS. This is no placebo, (unlike passive therapies) - this is the answer. Buy this book, invest in your total relief from Chronic pain. Sound too good to be true? Read it and be liberated.
5.0 out of 5 stars
If you have terrible pain problems, please read this book.,
By A Customer
This review is from: Freedom from Fibromyalgia: The 5-Week Program Proven to Conquer Pain (Paperback)
This doctor really knows how to fix chronic pain. She has fibromyalgia herself, and cured it. I went to see her about terrible chronic muscle problems due to overuse and fibromyalgia that had spread to all parts of my body. I had been dealing with this for 3+ years and the Mayo Clinic told me that there was nothing they could do. I finally gave up and tried this approach as a last resort (I am horribly skeptical of all forms of non-conventional treatment.) It seemed like a miracle when my pain cleared up and I got my life back. Most of the pain went away in 3-4 months. I still deal with it from time to time but I have the tools to deal with it now. This approach isn't easy, but with persistence it absolutely works. I still apply her methods and Dr. John Sarno's today, and am now very much in control of my disorder, thanks to her help. I highly recommend reading it and Dr. John Sarno's book, "The Mindbody Prescription." It really does work, especially it all conventional treatment has failed you.
5.0 out of 5 stars
It makes sense!,
By A Customer
This review is from: Freedom from Fibromyalgia: The 5-Week Program Proven to Conquer Pain (Paperback)
I am a retired teacher. I took early retirement due to my arthritis and Fibromyalgia. Freedom from Fibromyalgia makes more sense to me than anything I've read in the 15 years since I was diagnosed with this malady. (I "read" it by way of the Readers for the Blind and Handicapped, twice.)
1.0 out of 5 stars
Don't waste your money.,
By A Customer
This review is from: Freedom from Fibromyalgia: The 5-Week Program Proven to Conquer Pain (Paperback)
I will sum up premise in one sentence:"Tell your brain to stop causing tension and pain". Then, your FM will go away. If you believe what the authors say here is true, then Total Crap!!! Anyone that has done even a hint of research will tell you that the somatic disorder theory has been disproven. These authors should get FM. They deserve it.
1.0 out of 5 stars
Pure Non-sense in most cases.,
By A Customer
This review is from: Freedom from Fibromyalgia: The 5-Week Program Proven to Conquer Pain (Paperback)
Are there people with chronic muscle tension that couldhave repressed anger? Yes, of course. Are the majority of FM cases repressed anger? NO! Dr St Amand has pretty much proven that FM is caused by a phosphate retention problem. Read "What your Doctor Might not tell you about Fibromyalgia". I personally have taken Guaifenesin and seen mass amounts of phosphates and calcium come out in urine stream. I was overloaded. I still suffer but am improving. This book here is another of the "blame the patient" mentality that exists when doctors don't know what to do. So sick of it. Don't waste your money. |
|
Most Helpful First | Newest First
|
|
Freedom from Fibromyalgia: The 5-Week Program Proven to Conquer Pain by Franklynn Peterson (Paperback - May 8 2001)
Used & New from: CDN$ 16.41
| ||