Customer Reviews

Chinese Dim Sum: Wel-Chuan Cultural and Educational Foundation

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(4)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I've owned this cookbook for several years and use it as a reference all the time as Japanese Food Host at BellaOnline and as editor of GourMAsia, a newsletter on Asian food. Yet I can't say I've ever made one of the recipes as-is.

Like other cookbooks written by the famed Wei-Chuan Cooking School in Taiwan, the recipes in this book are highly authentic, and illustrated with step-by-step photographs. But be warned, for anyone looking to duplicate a Chinese dim sum experience at home: most are not by any means "easy to make." (Few types of dim sum are easy to make at home--which is precisely why Chinese families usually go out to Chinese restaurants for dim sum!)

Another warning is that the authenticity of these recipes means that not only do they call for specialized Asian ingredients, but for ingredients like lard and pork fat, which many Americans may prefer to avoid.

Measurements are given in metric and in strangely phrased avoirdupois weight (for instance, one dough recipe calls for 2/3 lb. flour, 1-1/3 oz. sugar, and 1/3 lb. water). So unless you have a metric scale, you'll have to do some weird calculations to figure them out (now, how much is 1/3 lb. water in cups?). Compounding the difficulties in following the recipes is their typical Asian format. Ingredients are listed in numbered sub-groups, and a sample of how the directions read is: "Wrap half the pieces of dough (3) in the pieces of dough (1). Wrap remaining pieces of dough (3) in the pieces of dough (2)."

Frankly, I prefer to eat my dim sum out and avoid the headaches of translating these recipes!

The Wei-Chuan Publishing Company (apparently connected with the Taiwanese Wei-Chuan Cooking School), has produced a good number of Cookbooks, mostly dealing with Chinese cookery but also coveing other Asian cuisines as well. I own over a dozen of these now and I like all of them. More importantly, I like all of these books for tmuch he same reasons and, accordingly, I have decided to do a general review that applies to each of them and then provide a few individualized comments where appropriate.

Basically, the Wei-Chuan publications are authored/editored by several different persons but the format is largely the same. Each book is divided into logical sections (Meats, Vegetables, Appetizers, etc.) and nearly every recipe is accompanied by a good photograph of the result with some recipes having additional pictures of the preparation as well. This feature alone makes these books well worth the purchase. Another feature of this cuilinary series is that the books are written in China and, at least as far as the books on Chinese cuisine is concerned, the reader need have no issues with 'authenticity'. I personally also like the fact that all of the books are written in Chinese characters and then translated into English. This has has an added bonus of occasionally providing some unintentional amusement due to a particularly 'unfortunate' translation but I specially like it as I am teaching myself Mandarin and these books are excellent learning tools. I often take one on the plane with me when I travel (along with dictionaries) and can spend hours happily translating passages. It is amazing how often the actual translation of a recipe title bears little resemblance to the English title provided.

Finally, I have to say that the recipes in all of these books are interesting and he ones that I have tried to reproduce have worked out well. Mainly though, I just like reading through these books for inspiration and enjoyment. The money I have spent has been repaid many times over.

The We-Chuan books I currently own are as follows:

Chinese Cuisine - Very good introductory section. Recipes range from simple everyday dishes to exotic banquet style delicacies.
Chinese Dim Sum: Wel-Chuan Cultural and Educational Foundation - Great 'step-by-step' pictures for many recipes. Bit too much emphasis on sweet rather than savoury for my personal taste.
Chinese Snacks - More of the same as in the Dim Sum book. No 'step-by-step' pictures but I actually like this book better.
Chinese Appetizers and Garnishes - I haven't attempted much from this book but I am thankful for the great 'step-by-step' pictures provided.

Favorite Home Dishes Chinese Cooking - As the name suggests, most of the recipes are simple and, thus, easy to prepare.

Chinese Cuisine Beijing Style - Lots of Imperial Banquet dishes and many exotic foreign influenced meals that have been 'Chinesified'.
Chinese Cuisine: Cantonese Style - 75 Cantonese recipes. Good recipes with nice pictures but a sparse introduction.
Chinese Cuisine Shanghai Style - Typically good Wei-Chuan quality but probably my least favorite of the 'regional' Chinese cookbooks.
Chinese Cuisine-Taiwanese Style - Excellent Book. Some truly unique recipes I have never seen elsewhere. I love to browse this volume.
Chinese Cuisine: Szechuan Style - I love Szechuan food especially but I would still treat this book as a favorite anyway.

Indian Cuisine - A nice book but be aware that the recipes Indian dishes for the Chinese palate, not Indian.
Vietnamese Cuisine - Great recipes.
Japanese Cuisine - Nearly as good as many books I have that are written by Japanese chefs.
Korean Cuisine - My favorite of the We-Chuan non-Chinese cookbooks so far,
Singaporean, Malaysian & Indonesian Cuisine - My least favorite Wei-Chuan book so far. Somewhat interesting but I don't look at it much.

Finally, I have a new Wei-Chuan book on order and will continue to buy from time to time. I will review separately as I read these new books.

I always thought dim sum would be difficult to make at home. Surprisingly, it isn't that tough after all! "Chinese Dim Sum" is one of the two most authentic of the dim sum cookbooks we've gotten. The recipes are written in both Chinese and English (side-by-side). Many use ingredients that people may have a hard time finding (such as leaf lard and red bean paste--some you can buy on line). The recipes are generally short, and laid out simply. Instructions are brief and numbered, and often accompanied by photos that show the processes involved. There are also gorgeous photos of finished recipes, showcasing ways in which you can make these dishes remarkably attractive and elegant.

I occasionally had difficulties with measurements. For example, in the recipe for red bean paste buns, some items are listed in tablespoons or teaspoons in the English version, but yeast was given in grams. Although we have a very good kitchen scale, it measures in 5-gram increments, so we had to guess when it came to measuring out 11 grams of yeast. Most items are given in both grams and ounces, but many kitchen scales can't measure, for example, 1/3 of an ounce. You're best off if you have a very accurate kitchen scale that measures grams, or at least enough experience in the kitchen to feel comfortable approximating.

These are fantastic recipes. Every single one we've made has been delightful. The red bean paste buns we made from this book were every bit as good as the ones I've had in restaurants, if not more so. The coconut buns were stunning as well, and the pork-filled pastries were melt-in-your-mouth delicious. (Their method of making the pastry dough is also surprisingly simple and non-difficult compared to some that I've tried.)

If you're willing to search around for ingredients (or have the right sort of store nearby) and you're interested in trying some truly authentic dim sum, I highly recommend this cookbook. The recipes are fabulous, and with a very sensitive kitchen scale the last few reservations I have would melt away.

I've said this before- i will say it again- i love the wei-chuan series!!! These books are fabulous and this one is no different!!! I read many of the reviews saying that the book is hard to follow. however i think that the book gives you crystal clear photos of what you basically need to know to get an idea as to what to do! This is a book people- not a video! If you need to watch someone doing this- watch eat,drink,man,woman! I guess i am at an advantage because i am chinese and have helped make this stuff before. My uncle is a dim sum chef in vancouver and it is amazing to watch. if you are making dim sum for the first time- expect it to be difficult, expect it to look like a ball of mush! I usually play around until i find my own rhythm. "Due to the variances of weather conditions, readers should adjust the liquid used in the recipes according to the local humidity. the knack may need a few tries before reaching perfection."

There's a great variety of steamed buns recipes- everything from the sweet bean past to pork and vegetable buns. (yes char siu bao is in there!) Steamed dumplings: pork, seafood, vegetarian ( these are good with spinach and mustard greens I couldn't figure out what ch'ing kang ts'ai meant!). Pot stickers and crepes (yeah- crepes- i didn't really understand the as-you-please crepes whose recipe includes mayonaise- it looks like a salad wrapped up in a crepe). It also has different recipes for congee or jook- the rice porridge.

i love the billingual aspect of the book- and the fact that it converts grams to lbs and oz. ! if you love Chinese food- or have just bought your child dim sum by grace lin- get this book! (you don't even have to cook- just looking at the pictures is enough!)

I received this book as a present form a friend who knows and share my enthusiasm about Dim-Sum. My passion as one who tries to produce those little delights, and his passion in consuming as much Dim-Sum as possible. As one reads this book, one conclusion comes to mind, this is a comprehensive- no frills book, written by a professional, may be even an artist, a master. The recipes were written and collected by people who have tried them many times over, every one is a gem. Those that can not be reproduced because of various reasons (lack or raw material for instance) make a good reading and reference. As one assumes that cooking in general, and highly specialized "regional" cooking is an art form or even a cultural statement that goes far and above the mechanical process of preparing food and consuming it. There is more then just a list of ingredients and steps to follow, so every recipe is worth reading and every recipe can benefit the one that tries to prepare better Dim-sum. READ this book even if you will never make a Dim-sum based on its recipes.
Having said this, I think that this book has a major flew, the process of making, folding a shaping the dumpling it self is left unclear, the numerous pictures in the book seem to skip this part or show a VERY obscure image of how to shape the dumpling. The end result is a real problem in preparing each and every on of the dumplings. Recipes of Dim-Sum that are more complicated or elaborate in appearance are almost impossible to complete. Since this is an important part of the process, one is left quite frustrated.

This is my favorite cookbook for dim sum. The recipes are authentic, letting one create the type of Cantonese dim sum treats one finds in Chinatowns or in Hong Kong. (For Taiwanese-style or Peking-style dim sum, my favorite is Wei-Chuan's cookbook in this series, entitled _Chinese Snacks_.) Be advised, though, that many of the recipes in this book specify quantities of ingredients by weight, both in metric and in avoirdupois/imperial/ounces, so a food scale is useful to have when using this book.

I've been eating dim sum all my life since I live only 10 minutes away from Chinatown. The recipes in this book comes out exactly like the restaurant's and bakeries. It's the best dim sum book I own!

I have try this book and I really like it. It have step by step instructions and even pictures. If you like dim sum, then this book is for you. Try it, you might like it.

This book travels inside Chinese food, and makes dim sum dishes out of it. Great book!

The recipes in this book is easy to follow. The ingredients also very easy to get. But anyone who ever go to a China town and eat Dim Sum there will know that Dim Sum it is not only about dumplings and buns ! They serve more than just that. I hope Wei-Chuan will add more recipes such as chicken feet !