on December 15, 2012
I loved this very frank and forthright book on the way psychiatry is practiced in the current age. To me there was an extra level of interest, since I myself trained in medicine, and I worked in general practice for eight years before having to stop working due to severe depression. I have to agree with everything Dr Carlat has written, especially as to how the profession now mainly treats sypmtoms rather than causes. I spent years on a merry-go-round of various pharmaceutical cocktails such as what is described in the book, without any psychiatrist actually getting at the root cause of my depression. The risks he describes are all true and shamefully little discussed by prescribing psychiatrists - this book is a gold mine of information for the unsuspecting patient and I would recommend it to anyone who is considering treatment with a psychotropic medication.
on January 16, 2016
Daniel Carlat is a psychiatrist who loves his profession enough to expose its considerable weaknesses. Psychiatry will be better for this in the long run. In addition to dishing up some criticism, though, he takes time to show patients (and readers) how psychiatrists think, how psychiatric assessments are conducted, and how this profession has evolved. Warm, readable and memorable.