Customer Reviews


2 Reviews
5 star:
 (2)
4 star:    (0)
3 star:    (0)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 
Most Helpful First | Newest First

5.0 out of 5 stars A brilliant explanation of "the practice of effective management", Sept. 17 2012
By 
Robert Morris (Dallas, Texas) - See all my reviews
(TOP 10 REVIEWER)    (HALL OF FAME)    (REAL NAME)   
This review is from: Managing (Hardcover)
Whenever I ask someone, "What does a manager manage that is most important?", some respond people, others work to be done, and still others resources. Thus far, no one has suggested what I think is most important: managing one's self effectively. That determines how well or how poorly one manages anyone or anything else. Mintzberg apparently agrees because in this book, as he explains, "I observed twenty-nine different managers for a day each, writing this up in straight [begin italics] descriptions [end italics] of what happened (as well as what was discussed) and conceptual [begin italics] interpretations [end italics] of what I could make of these descriptions." They comprise a remarkably diverse group in that their members represent all three of "conventional hierarchy levels" of management (top, middle, and bottom) in all sorts of organizations (i.e. business, government, health care, and social sector) located in major urban centers as well as more remote locations (e.g. Ngara, Tanzania). He was curious to know what they did, how and why they did it, and what their own perspectives on management are.

Here's a passage in the first chapter that caught my eye: "It has been fashionable to distinguish leaders from managers...Frankly, I don't understand what this distinction means in the everyday life of organizations. Sure, we can separate leading and managing conceptually. But can we separate them in practice? Or, more to the point, should we even try?" My own opinion is that in the healthiest organizations (whatever their size and nature may be), everyone at all levels and in all areas of operation lead or manage, depending on what is needed in the given situation. Consider this mosaic of Mintzberg's own thoughts about various key issues:

"I believe we are now overled and undermanaged...In other words, leadership cannot simply delegate management; instead of distinguishing managers from leaders, we should be seeing managers [begin italics] as [end italics] leaders, and leadership as management practiced well...The more we obsess about leadership, the less of it we seem to get...Accordingly, this book puts managing ahead, seeing it together with leadership as naturally embedded in what can be called [begin italics] communityship [end italics]...It is to recognize that managing is neither a science nor a profession; it is a practice, learned primarily through experience, and rooted in context...Put together a good deal of craft with the right touch of art alongside some use if science, and you end up with a job that is above all a [begin italics] practice [end italics]...The manager, by the definition used here, is someone responsible for the whole organization or some identifiable part of it. [Moreover] the manager has to help bring out the best in other people, so that [begin italics] they [end italics] can know better, decide better, and act better. [Therefore] let's recognize management as a [begin italics] calling [end italics], and so appreciate that efforts to professionalize it, and turn it into a science, undermine that calling."

The material that Mintzberg provides this narrative is best viewed as his contribution to a deeper understanding and wider application of the core principles of what he views as the practice of effective management. Here are several of the areas that he rigorously examines:

The material that Mintzberg provides his narrative is best viewed as his contribution to a deeper understanding and wider application of the core principles of what he views as the practice of effective management. Here are several of the areas that he rigorously examines...and illuminates:

o "Toward a General Model of Managing" (Pages 47-50)
o "Strategic Planning as Framing? Deeming? Scheduling?" (63)
o "Some Myths of the Conductor as Leader" (71)
o Table 3.1 "ROLES OF MANAGING" (91)
o Table 3.2 "COMPETENCIES OF MANAGING" (92)
o "Form of Organization" (106-108)
o "The Job Context" (109-115)
o "The Temporal Context" (115-121)
o "Personal Styles of Managing" (121-133)
o "The Dilemma of Delegation" (173-179)
o "The Riddle of Change" (189-191)
o "A Framework for Effectiveness" (206-207)
o "Assessing Managerial Effectiveness" (221-225)
o "Development: From Management to Organization to Society to Self" (230-231)

Readers will especially appreciate, also, the material provided in the Appendix as Mintzberg provides the aforementioned "descriptions" of the day spent with eight of the managers "to anchor the use of this material in the book and to illustrate the rich and varied realities of managing" in a real-world context. "The descriptions of all twenty-nine days, as well as their conceptual interpretations, are available on 3wmintzberg-managingdotcom, which is almost as long as the text of this book itself.

Those who share by high regard for this book are urged to check out other books by Mintzberg, notably The Nature of Managerial Work (1973), Mintzberg on Management: Inside Our Strange World of Organizations (1989), Strategy Safari, co-authored with Bruce Ahlstrand and Joseph Lampel (1998), Tracking Strategies: Towards a General Theory of Strategy Formation (2007), and Management? It's not What You Think! co-authored with Ahlstrand and Lampel (2009).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars A useful book by a business professor who understands management, Oct. 25 2011
This review is from: Managing (Hardcover)
If you are familiar with the usual lows of the management books genre, Mintzberg's work is a pleasant surprise: you don't find here yet another pointless "study" full of trivia and gossips about glamorous CEOs earning tens of millions managing well known multi-billion dollar corporations.

The author's beginning point is simple: "We can neither do without managers nor afford to idolize them" (p.148).

His approach outlines a fruitful and novel framework for evaluating and building effective management. Like Drucker, Mintzberg recognizes that general management is a genuinely independent discipline. On the novelty side, he persuasively argues that management is most importantly a PRACTICE which, quite unmetaphorically, has the dimensions of art, craft and science.

In addition to providing a fruitful and practical evaluation framework, this book presents a detailed argument, backed up by useful study cases, designed to show that general management is not reducible neither to a sum of its functional sub-disciplines such as accounting, HR, operations, sales, marketing, project management and technology nor to semi-mystical personal qualities of charisma/leadership beloved by "business gurus" and self-help books industry.

Recommended read for managers, board members and aspiring managers.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Managing
Managing by Henry Mintzberg (Hardcover - Sept. 1 2009)
CDN$ 28.92 CDN$ 18.54
In Stock
Add to cart Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews