countdown boutiques-francophones Learn more vpcflyout Home All-New Kindle Music Deals Store sports Tools Registry

Customer Reviews

3.6 out of 5 stars
3.6 out of 5 stars
Format: Audio CD|Change
Price:$9.97+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on August 30, 2000
The Band is one of my favorite bands, and their first two albums are unanimously prized as two landmarks in rock history. In recent years, people have come to appreciate later, underrated albums like "Stage Fright" and "Rock of Ages." However, popular opinion for "Cahoots" hasn't gotten much better, and for good reason. Very few of the original album tracks are good, and only two tracks, "4% Pantomime" (a great duet between Van Morrison and the late Richard Manuel) and "Life Is A Carnival," could be ranked as true, great Band classics. Actually, "Life Is A Carnival" never felt like much of a song; what really breathes life into it is the exuberant horn arrangement done by legendary rock producer/arranger/writer Allen Toussaint. Another popular favorite from this album is "When I Paint My Masterpiece," a good Dylan song that doesn't quite get the definitive treatment here (I heard Robbie Robertson actually hated the final recording). As for the rest, there's nothing abysmal or unlistenable. It's just not all that good.
What does make this album worth owning now is the new reissue by Capitol. For one thing, the sound is a lot better, having been remastered with state-of-the-art technology as well as the original master tapes. But more important than better sound is the legendary studio version of "Don't Do It," by far the best bonus track on the reissue. I've always loved the Band's rendition of this song ever since I saw them perform it in their film, "The Last Waltz." For years, the only official release of this song was a great live version from "Rock of Ages," but unbelievably this studio take is even better. The sound isn't phenomenal (the only available source was a demo record), but it crushes every version ever made like a grape. It's arguably the only Motown song that was done better by someone else.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on April 18, 2002
It is eery listening to this record in light of their better work--the voices are the same, the instrumental virtuosity evident if not on full display. It starts off well (Carnival, Masterpiece), then doesn't go anywhere. I guess the problem is the pretentious songwriting, which seems to have dampened everyone's enthusiasm for the project. The bonus tracks just highlight this: the Motown chestnut "Don't Do It", despite inferior sound quality, is now one of the best tracks. The cover painting says it all--5 wizened men standing somberly behind a crypt. Perfect depiction of the dreary music inside. Back photo is also on track, the five with their eyes closed--Levon's furrowed brow the tipoff. Is it only a rumor that one of the outtakes from the photo session has them holding their noses? Tip: their second lp, The Band, is a must have. Their first, Big Pink, plus one of the many best ofs, is all you need to round it out.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on December 11, 2003
If your a band fan already read on. If not I recommend starting with 'The Band' or 'Rock of Ages' albums first. It has been well documented that 'Cahoots' is supposedly a poor album compared with the others. While most of the tracks aren't exceptional, such as on 'The Band', this album contains two of the best Rick Danko sung Band songs of their collection. 'Where Do We Go From Here' is a well crafted song that is beautifully sung. The liner notes suggest that Robbie Robertson wishes The Band had taken this song further. If they had, it would have been phenomenal. The other song is 'Thinkin' Out Loud'. This track features Garth on piano and Richard on Drums. The arrangement is superb. The vocal blend on both tracks is reminiscent of their 'classic'sound. If you're a Band fan and haven't already got this album then I recommend you get it for these tracks alone. The rest of the album is o.k. but nothing to spectacular.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on May 1, 2001
Many critics consider Cahoots a disappointment as it doesn't live up to their first three albums. It is true that it isn't in the league of the first three, but that's all relative. Cahoots is a solid, sometimes spectacular album that shows off the group's musical prowess by playing over 40 different instruments and Robbie Robertson's supreme wordsmanship. "Life Is A Carnival" is an apply named song as it has a carnival like sound with the cacophony of horns. "4% Pantomime" is an excellent song that features Van Morrison in duet with Richard Manuel. "Shootout In Chinatown" has sharp imagery and "Thinkin' Out Loud" is an underrated track. "When I Paint My Masterpiece" is an all right cover of a Bob Dylan song, but somewhat disappointing considering their track record with his songs. All in all, Cahoots is worth a listen.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on May 26, 2001
Maybe it didn't sell as well as earlier albums, and maybe some critics didn't like it, but as a musician I'm here to tell you it's terrific. I'd give it 5*s but that has to be reserved for the truly great Rock of Ages set. Face it, The Band never appealed to the masses -- they just went over the average person's head, I think. This disc has some truly remarkable performances, and belongs in every Band fan's collection, as does the entire reissue series. All are uniformly well produced -- the clarity is amazing -- and taken all together, the liner notes form a detailed and well written history of the group's output. Shoot Out in Chinatown, Volcano, and Thinkin' Out Loud are standout songs, and Life is a Carnival is still a masterpiece.
Stumbled? No, they just veered off in a direction no one predicted, when the critics wanted another "brown album."
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on December 11, 2000
This reissue is worth it for the extra tracks, especially the early studio take of "Endless Highway" sung by the great Richard Manuel. "Bessie Smith" is another excellent extra track, featuring a rare vocal from Robbie Robertson. As far as the original tracks, "Last of the the Blacksmiths", "The Moon Struck One", and "4% Pantomine" all allow Manuel to showcase his tremendous voice once again. On "4%" he duets with Van Morrison on a song , interestingly enough, about the difference between Johnnie Walker Red and Johnnie Walker Black scotch. ('s the proof). If you're just getting into The Band, and you think they stopped making great make music after the first two albums, buy this album. With the extra tracks, it is probably a more solid album than "Stage Fright".
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on September 7, 2000
To call this album the worst Band album is accurate to a degree, but also a bit misleading. The thing is this: it's not by any stretch of the imagaination a "bad" album. The songs are a bit weak in spots, sure, but the way these guys *PLAY*!!... they could make a brittney spears song sound good!
It does have a couple of classics: "4% Pantomine" s utterly great, and "Moon Struck one" is one of Robertson's most bizarre compositions. The cover of "When I Paint my masterpiece" is absolutely great.
Even when these guys were "off" they were great!
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on February 4, 2014
I should have sent this back, but I was busy and did not have time. The copy that I received was flawed and it skipped several times on my platter. I cleaned it, but it still skips. My turntable and stylus are correctly balanced.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on February 4, 2003
Remove the awful Smoke Signal and Volcano, and Cahoots would hold up well with The Band's prior albums. Cahoots has a wide variety of styles and experimentation, so it's not surprising that it draws a mixed reaction. I think the two tunes mentioned above, which run in succession and are the first truly bad songs appearing on a Band album, are a serious drawback. The rest of the album is excellent.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on February 3, 2002
A not too bad CD with a couple of real gems like Carnival and Masterepiece. Van Morrison adds a nice touch too. The Band had very much reached a creative cul de sac by the time of Cahoots, thankfully they turned it all around for the superb Northern Lights-Southern Cross. Still, even a burnt out weary effort by the truest of bands provides for interesting listening.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse