Customer Reviews

Signs

5 star:		(268)
4 star:		(152)
3 star:		(109)
2 star:		(79)
1 star:		(142)

 

 

With M. Night Shyamalan's third major studio release as director, he once again proved that he may just be heir to the Hitchcock throne of suspense. Do not think I am comparing him to the level of Hitchcock as a film maker, because Shyamalan still has a long way to go to achieve that goal. However, of the film makers today you'd be hard pressed to find a director who could produce such a suspenseful film on such minimalist methods.

Hollywood's mentality has long been the bigger the explosion the bigger the return, and in an age of special effects and showing off what they can do on the computer (take note, George Lucas), Shyamalan bypassed all that and harkened back to a time when the most important thing was the story. Shyamalan constructed the film around the history and idiosyncracies of the family using everyday things such as half-filled glasses, a baby monitor, and other like things. When Spielberg directed Jaws, he learned that by not showing the shark that much made the film much more effective (admittedly, this realisation came to be because JAWS was such a production disastor). In a time when we have the specials effects to envision anything you could possibly dream, this film aptly illustrates that just because you have the technology it doesn't mean you have to use it to tell a good story. The old adage of "less is more" fits wonderfully here. Another wonderful example that incorporates technology without sacrificing the story or characters is Minority Report.

What is so remarkable about Signs' plot? It's the fact that the characters exist in their own right and never feel like just plot devices or mouthpieces. Mel Gibson plays an apostate preacher who suddenly has to handle the fact that crop circles are appearing in his corn field. Simultaneously, all across the globe crop circles are, shall we say, cropping up. His children (Rory Culkin, Abigail Breslin) and his brother (Joaquin Phoenix from Gladiator) begin believing in the aliens, and try as he might Gibson's character realizes that these crop circles won't just go away. The movie then moves to the question is are these alien formations, and if so what are they used for? If there are aliens, are they hostile or not? What do they want with Earth?

Because Shyamalan always mades sure the Gibson's character and his family are in the forefront, the viewer becomes involved with them as individual characters to the point where the aliens are more events anything else. More and more scripts have characters taking backseat to the special effects and this is sapping the film industry of vitality. In Signs, when Morgan (the son) has his asthma attack during an assault on the house, we are much more concerned with what effect it would have on the family if they lost him, instead of it being some cheap and lowbrow ploy that is more of a plot device than a character study (Panic Room anyone?).

One of the key themes in Signs is faith. This film deals with the anger that Gibson's character feels toward God and how he must work through that throughout life's circumstances. Shyamalan's character (yes, he acts) is responsible for Gibson losing his faith. The film traces Gibson's progression of losing his faith and then struggling with God over losing his wife. This is illustrated ingeniously in the film's climax.

While my faith in God hasn't left me, my faith in Hollywood has long since evaporated. With directors such as Shyamalan still on the go-around, I find it getting a little stronger everyday.

Quickly: disapointing, not that scary.

Summary: Priest loses wife, then loses faith and is left raising 2 kids with the help of his brother. Creepy things happen, it ends up it's aliens, they all hide, then fight one alien and learn that there reall is a god.

The Good: I actually liked the little girl, she was just creepy enough and not annoying. I thought Gibson did a great job playing the lost father. I loved the fact that this movie used The Hidden Fortress plot device. It told the story from the eyes of its lowest characters. A huge war is going on and instead of seeing the war we see 4 people watching the news about the War. The alien was rather cool once you got to it, I loved the camo effect.

The Bad: It just wasn't really that scary or clever. I expected way more from this (as I am pretty sure everyone else did when it came out). There was no plot twist at the end, that made me re-think the whole movie. There wasn't really even a 'jump' worthy cheap scare. It just didn't have what I expected in it.

The Ugly: Hidding in a boarded up house and then in a celler is the stuff of Zombie movies not Alien Invasion movies. The movie builds up so much suspense of the coming invasion, and we get to see people fumbling around in the dark and one alien.

Overall: this was pretty disapointing. Amusingly we owned this for a few years, and haven't watched it since most of our DVD watching starts during dinner. We didn't want to watch a horror while eating. Well we could have watched this one. It's just not scary. Not being scary I at least expected some big revalation at the end that made you think, a "What he was a Ghost?!?" moment. Technically there was one, but it just didn't work for me.

"Signs" is,undobtedly, one of the most misunderstood films in recent memory. It is also one of the most brilliantly conceived and executed films in many a year. The heart of the movie lies NOT with the outward ET invasion, but with the father's inward crisis of faith.

The film asks the the timeless and difficult question that philosophers and theologians have asked for centuries. Is the world is just a hodgepodge of chance and coincidence, and therefore, meaningless, or is the universe guided by some metaphysical force, implying a purpose to everything that happens. Are we on our own, at the mercy of a cruel and unjust universe, or is there someone looking out for our welfare?

The director uses the alien theme to create a suspeneseful scenario ala Hitchcock, but infuses it with a profound, underlying structure ala Ingmar Bergman. He also throws in mystical elements such as the healing and life giving power of water ala director Tom Tykwer (of "The Princess and the Warrior" fame). The many layers produce a complex and thought-provoking film that should not be missed.

"Signs" is M. Night Shyamalan's best movie, and one of my favorite suspense films. It is also so ridiculously underrated! Many people hate it because of its religious aspects, its ending, and it wasn't what they had expected. Come on people! This film isn't about big explosions or special effects. It's about characters that you come to know and care about. That is what makes it a great movie. Great movies are about characters, NOT special effects. Anyway, what I love about this film is the humor that comes from the supporting characters, and it has a sweet and beautiful little girl in it. Abigail Breslin, as Bo Hess, is the kind of little girl you'd love to have as your own. She's so adorable and hilarious, and she pulled my heartstrings at the right moments. I hope she makes more films in the future.

This is one of my all-time favorite movies! When I saw it in the theater, it literally startled me at times so that I fell out of my chair! Also very emotionally moving, it's just a plain great flick. BUY IT IF: you like to be scared, entertained and moved all in the same 2 hours. DON'T BUY IT IF: you've already seen it more than once. It isn't of much value after you know what happens.

Signs is by far one of the creepiest movies I have ever seen. It's not scary, it just leaves you breathless with shock. I guess that's why they call these movies thrillers.

There's not really much you can say without giving away the plot but it's one hell of a good movie. I was disappointed with the way the movie ended - I was expecting more of an explanation to the aliens.

This movie is a good buy and I recommend it to horror movie fans and people that enjoy good jumpy thrillers.

Shyamalan did everything right with Signs. Not only does he hold true to his practice of a surprise ending, but the ride to the ending is just as much fun. If you're looking for a shoot-em-up alien movie, if all you're interested in is seeing alien guts and lots of special effects, look elsewhere. This is very much a psychological movie about fear, hope, and faith. Mel Gibson's performance is very high quality, and the rest of the cast supports well. I highly recommend this movie to anyone who's not afraid to think a little.

M. Night Shyamalan's Signs is a unique and powerful sci-fi thriller. Fans of The Sixth Sense and The Others should enjoy this film though it doesn't have ghosts or a surprise ending. Signs is subtle in its creepiness and grand in emotion. The relationship between Mel Gibson's character and his children is touching, and the idea of having faith is something to take to heart. Signs is a simple yet ambitious movie that focuses more on personal relationships and drama. We don't see hoards of aliens or spacecraft, laser blasts or explosions. Instead, we see a family struggling to survive and stay strong. Though some of premise of the film is a little far-fetched, it still feels frighteningly real.

I read some of the reviews posted and was surprised at how many people didn't enjoy this movie. I felt it was very good,it had
a good storyline, some mystery and stirred up the emotions.
It also gave some food for thought, since none of us really know how those crop circles get in the fields, now do we?
I give this one a thumbs up! Good job!

The tagline sums this movie up. It's about a preacher turned farmer (Mel Gibson), his brother (Joaquin Pheonix) and his children. After they discover crop circles in their farm, they are threatened with an alien invasion.

This movie was brilliantly shot. M. Night Shyamalan captures the sets beautifully, and makes this movie chilling and scary. The movie was genuinely scary, and didn't need special effects to make me scared. I watched it and was chilled. The acting was sometimes a little over-the-top, but it was still good. The children were chilling, and Gibson does a good job. The story had its holes but was still a chilling and good story. Don't expect this movie to change your life, but it will scare you and keep you entertained for a couple hours.