Customer Reviews

The Girl Next Door

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This movie is the most disturbing movie i have ever seem. I almost puked. I have never seen anything so graphic in my life. After watching the movie i had to get it out of my house. I never want to see it again. It has been a week since watching it and not a day goes by that i do not think about those girls

Well, after all the spoilers in the previous review, you already know what this movie is about so I avoid duplication. However, that said, it certainly is not recommended for sensitive viewers. I can watch slasher movies, spook and gore without turning a hair but movies which focus exclusively on torture, which this one does, I find very disturbing, even more so because this one is fact based.

My quirks aside, I can definitely acknowledge superb performances from Blythe Auffarth as Meg and Blanche Baker, with a plus for the latter who offered award worthy spine chilling indifference as the sociopath, Ruth. I should have rented it; for me, it was a watch once movie.

This precious girl, Sylvia went through so much misery and degration at the hands of this "Witch" is the only name that comes to mind. She, her kids and all the kids in the neighbour-hood had a great old time tying Sylvia up and having the other boys abuse her while she watched. Throwing Sylvia down the stairs over and over again was a thrill for all the boys. This book is very heartbreaking to read, I myself cried over all the abuse that was inflicked on this poor soul. R.I.P. Sylvia.

Very good acting and very believable subject matter, could be happening in your own neighborhood - mostly a very tabu subject

Sick and disturbing!! I just can't stop thinking about it. The sad part is that it is based on a true story.

Talk about being numb to your seat. Even though I've been warned I was still angered by it. I never cuss and fuss so much towards a film in my life. As a parent I was totally appalled of all the actions that took place towards the sisters. Just because your (Ruth) life ended up bad doesn't mean you can take it upon a child. She's lucky I didn't bump into her in the streets but fortunately enough she got what she deserves. In the beginning of this film, it revolves around David (played as an adult by William Atherton, the seminal 1980s), who after seeing a man hit by a car, recalls his youth and meeting Meg Loughlin (Blythe Auffarth), a 13 year old daughter of a gypsy left with her mother under the care of Ruth (Blanche Baker) and her sons. The young David (played by Daniel Manche) grows fond of his neighbors and Ruth, as she lets the boys drink beer, smoke cigarettes, and give them whatever they want. However, Ruth grows spiteful of Meg and her younger sister Susan (Madeline Taylor), crippled from polio. She starts with verbal abuse, and it soon turns into something more violent, as Ruth and her sons tie up Meg in the basement, and allow the neighborhood kids to torture her with cigarette burns, rape, and branding hot needles into her skin. David seems helpless, but slowly tries to find the courage to help her.

The film starts out like any coming of age film, where David meets his new neighbors and the first act shows David's induction into Ruth's house. The second act begins the torture, and the third act is David's belated reaction to do something about it. It is successful on the filmmakers to have me react so strongly every time Ruth and her sons appeared on screen, because I know that's what they are going for. However, I felt that the process they used felt more exploitative than most. It shows in a scene before Meg's torture, where Ruth punishes Susan by dropping her pants and spanking her with a toilet bowl cleaner. We only see a view from below the bed, where Susan lies, but to see her braces fall to the ground as each slap is heard just felt sickening. The slow torture of Meg was very unpleasant to watch, and just went to a level so far it became exploitative. I know this really happened, but it didn't need to go to that level to show the point they needed to make. The director did state that the kids weren't there for explicit scenes but they were all there for Meg's first scene at the basement.

Blythe Auffarth undeniably gave a brave performance as Meg, giving one of the most gut wrenching performances I've seen in a film. It is her suffering that sells the film and she succeeds admirably. Not every actress would do this role, and she should be applauded. Blanche Baker is such an evil (BEEP) as Ruth that she just made my stomach churn at her presence. Her sons were all played well as spoiled brats enjoying the evil acts they are doing, showing that children can prove to be as cruel as adults. These kids make Stewie from FAMILY GUY look like Opie Taylor. William Atherton is good as the adult David, but his scenes feel out of place and don't really provide any resolution. I've always liked Atherton as an actor, and I wish he had more to do. Some of the reviewers here along with my friends at Amazon had stated that "The Girl Next Door" is the most shocking for 07' and probably for the decade which I too agree upon. It's well directed, brilliantly acted (by some), and well written, but overall it's a film not made for the right reasons, and made to exploit your anger at the shocking elements of the film rather than bring this harrowing subject matter to the attention it deserves. They say the book is better then the movie, sorry I doubt I'll ever pick that up.