Auto boutiques-francophones Simple and secure cloud storage giftguide Kitchen Kindle Black Friday Deals Week in Music SGG Tools

Customer Reviews

4.3 out of 5 stars24
4.3 out of 5 stars
Format: Audio CDChange
Price:$20.19+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

17 of 17 people found the following review helpful
TOP 500 REVIEWERon September 27, 2008
This latest offering from David Gilmour has Richard Wright's death just after its release, the location and the marking of the historical anniversary of the event add up to make this a landmark in both a wonderful and an uncanny way.

That aside, this is one really impressive live album, the kind you wish had been made for some of Pink Floyd's greatest tours. ( '73, '75 & '77 specifically ) The sound is sharp and clear, with a very wide range of highs and lows. But what else would you expect from a Pink Floyd alumnus? Floyd's tours were always amazing for their sheer size and spectacle, the breathtaking lights, screen projections, fireworks and effects but also largely because of a quality of sound that no one has been able to equal since. With their massive quad sound system they could turn the largest stadium into a behemoth set of headphones, often achieving a production sound that even surpassed their immactulately recorded albums.

"Live in Gdansk" seems to follow in the tradition royally.

While the set list is almost the same as heard at the Albert Hall for "Remember That Night", there are some really lovely and jaw-dropping re-workings of certain numbers and a few new treats that make "Gdansk" a MUST for the devoted. The addition of the Baltic Philharmonic Symphony on stage both fleshes out and uplifts Gilmour's newest work as well as spicing up some of the Floyd faves as well.

David Crosby and Graham Nash are NOT in attendance at this event and it takes a while to get used to their absence at certain points. But the band's vocalists, which is everyone save for Dick Parry, do a beautiful job of it regardless. Where Messrs Crosby and Nash really are missed is on "Shine on You Crazy Diamond", where the addition of their harmonies to Gilmour's new arrangement at the Royal Albert Hall took the classic song into sublimity.

Well worth watching is the "Gdansk Diary", a documentary of the event marking of the creation of "Solidarity" by Lech Walesa in the Gdansk shipyards. Gilmour plays down his role and wonders himself why he was asked to be the musician invited to mark the occasion. There is one very telling and powerful moment when he is being interviewed by the Polish media. He sits patiently while questions are first posed in the native tongue and are them translated for him. During one such question you hear a few lines of Polish being spoken while Gilmour patientlly waits for the ensuing translation. Popping almost sharply out of the unfamiliar stream of the Slavic language comes two words that change Gilmour's facial expression - "Roger Waters". Almost instantaneously he recovers, blinks once and smiles, looks toward the camera and says. "Oh, was that the time? Is it time now?". Interview over.

"Gdansk" is well worth the purchase, whether it be just the 2-disc audio only set, the 2-disc, 1 DVD set or the full on four disc, 2 CD, 2 DVD set. The band is very comfortably experienced with the material and it shows, Gilmour having retained them from their world tour. They have all the many nuances of the music down and are able to stretch out with it while maintaining its essential integrity. "On an Island" is beautifully represented here and the Floyd material contains some of the best versions ever recorded.

"Astronomy Domine" is barely contained and fiercely intense, played with total committment and belief. An old psychedelic chestnut perhaps but here it feels briskly and electrically new, almost frighteningly wild.

"Echoes", on "Gdansk", is hands down, the greatest version ever recorded. It is so intensely powerful, so articulately played and inventively treated that nothing else ever released comes close. It clocks in at a massive 25 minutes. Each of it's 3 instrumental sections are expanded to the point of amazement and excitement, but never reaching the point of indulgence. It takes mastery and experience to take a large and hugely adored classic like "Echoes" and breathe such new fire and thunder into it. It reminds one that it was songs like "Echoes" that truly made Pink Floyd great. Gilmour and Wright are ON FIRE here!

Nevermind "Money" and "Another Brick in the Wall", "Echoes" is what those of us who came on board with Floyd pre-"Dark Side" were so rapturous about. Here, on this release, it is given a volcanically powerful new life. Gilmour and Wright's antiphonal "outro" is delicate and exquisite, so tasteful and bluesy that you want it to go on and on. Now with Wright's passing it takes on a kind of sweet sadness and poignancy that reminds us of Wright's own, largely unacknowledged, high level of musicianship. Pink Floyd could not have achieved their greatness without him.

On the concert DVD we see Wright receive a wildly enthusiastic standing ovation, which, it was since said by Gilmour, surprised him nightly. The irony was that to Gilmour and the other band members it was no surprise at all. Of Wright he said in his statement after his long-time friend's death, "Where would "Dark Side of the Moon" be without "The Great Gig in the Sky" and "Us and Them"?, both songs composed by Wright. Gilmour felt that all of Floyd's greatest moments where "when Richard was in full flow". On "Gdansk", which turned out to be Wright's epitaph, he is indeed in full flow, full flight. It his heartening to think that at the end of his, sometimes very sad, life Richard Wright, unrelentingly backed and loved by Gilmour, achieved himself and his full talent again.

Truly a landmark for it's occasion but also for the strange irony of the end of the truly most musical half of Pink Floyd ( Gilmour and Wright ) as well as it's sheer monumental musicality. "Gdansk" is already a classic.
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful
TOP 50 REVIEWERon September 23, 2008
Mine came in the mail this morning and what a great package. The DVD with the concert is in 5.1 and does have some song changes from "Remember That Night". It comes with a 45 min. Doc and ton's of extra tracks. The best thing is the DTS 5.1 remix of the studio CD "On An Island" It has much warmer sound then the CD and the mix is perfect. I know this is pricy but i really think it is worth the money.
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
on October 26, 2010
This, limited five disc (three CDs + two DVDs) edition is great for those who just want to enjoy the music, but even better for those who have a great collection of music concerts. In the box you will find a poster, some photos, sticker, a ticket for the show...
What to say about David, about the show? You always get what you expect, even more. This is no exception. Definitely one of the best concerts I have ever seen in my life, and I've seen a lot.
A must for everyone who loves Pink Floyd and David Gilmour.
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
on February 14, 2009
This is a very good album specially the version with the DVD(S)because it's a farewell to Pink Floyd's Richard Wright also we get the electric guitar virtuoso performance of David Gilmour which i consider as one of the best guitarist alive today,a must have for every Pink Floyd fan
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
on April 24, 2009
Anyone who likes Pink Floyd, David Gilmour, Richard in for a treat. This live performance really showcases the ability of some of rock's most talented musicians. The 4 disc version is fantastic.
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on July 13, 2015
Wow. Excellent double CD and then there's a 25:35 version of Echoes. That is worth the price alone. Thoroughly enjoying the 4th straight listen to right now.
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on October 4, 2015
Absolutely amazing show from David Gilmour. The choir has done a great job too. Must buy for all those David Gilmour and Pink Floyd fans.
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on December 1, 2013
david gilmour live in gdansk with the baltic philharmonic symphony orchestra two cd 22 songs very good album great price
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on October 16, 2015
Hours of quality entertainment. Very worth the price. Gilmour is a genius! A true treasure.
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful
TOP 500 REVIEWERon November 28, 2008
After having a chance to listen and watch this [thanks to a friend], I'm not rushing to buy this. On the non-technical side, these multiple releases are way overpriced [I think there are at least 6 variations].

As for the material, some repeats the previous DVD set [Royal Albert] or includes material that should of been in one place instead of 2 separate releases. As well, why is some of the concert only available on CD and some only available on DVD? The 3rd CD on the 3CD/2DVD edition can also be pulled off Gilmour's site [or so it looks]. Finally, Gilmour left out all his solo material except the last album which [outside of 2-3 tracks] is boring as hell [you don't want to drive home at night with it playing - you''ll fall asleep]. Clearly About Face should of had a few songs on it. Just about the same Pink Floyd material on Royal Albert is here as well]. Only bright spot was the production.
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Rattle That Lock
Rattle That Lock by David Gilmour (Audio CD - 2015)

David Gilmour: Remember That Night [Blu-ray]
David Gilmour: Remember That Night [Blu-ray] by David Gilmour (Blu-ray - 2007)
CDN$ 39.69

On An Island (Ltd.Ed) (Vinyl)
On An Island (Ltd.Ed) (Vinyl) by David Gilmour (LP Record - 2010)