Most Helpful First | Newest First
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars We're in the Exo-Space Time Continuum,
Three videos in one review? Well, let me give it a shot!
Full Circle: In Adric's debut story, the Doctor and Romana go through a CVE (Charged Vacuum Emboitment), en route to Gallifrey, and land on the planet Alzarius. The planet is experiencing Mistfall, a bubbling of the mists that bring out the Marshmen.
Adric is caught between sides. On one hand, he feels stifled by the conventions of society, but the Outlers, led by his brother Varsh, see him as part of the establishment. Naturally, there is only one place for him, as the viewer will see at the end.
The paralysis of the Alzarian "Type D Oligarchy" is painfully aware, as the Deciders have enforced a policy of deliberate ignorance on its citizens, and are guilty of "willful procrastination." As Login says: "A little patience goes a long way." The Doctor replies: "Too much patience goes nowhere." The strongest supporting character is George Baker who plays the decisive Decider Login, the most respected member of the community, who in the end gets something done. Second place goes to June Page as Keara, Login's Outler daughter, who would have been an ideal companion, but Nyssa came along in Keeper Of Traken.
This is a story with a mystery that is gradually revealed bit by bit, and it works effectively to that effect. Clues include Decider Nefred's pained reaction on seeing the system files, Draith's dying words: "Tell Dexeter we've come full circle," and the pain shared by the Marsh child, being dissected by Dexeter, and Romana, who has an alien protein injected in her from a spider bite.
The Doctor's carelessness of leaving the Starliner door open leads to the Marsh child's entering the Starliner, subsequent capture, and death. Surprising for his character. And the rising of the Marshmen from the swamp is effectively realized. And those marsh spiders are creepy-looking!
State Of Decay: Still in Exo-space, The TARDIS lands on a planet, "a typical medieval scene," dominated by a "protective castle with village dwellings huddled like ducklings around their mother." Reading, science, and knowledge are capital crimes, but that doesn't stop a secret rebel movement.
It turns out that the castle is actually an Earth ship that got [pulled] into E-Space a millennium ago. And who are the "Three Who Rule, apart from being King Zargo, Queen Camilla, and Councillor Aukon? A cloud of bats, courtesy of effective stock footage, and fuel tanks filled with blood gives the Doctor "a suspicion, but it's too horrible to think about."
The Doctor has a good line when Romana asks him how he knew there was another planet in E-Space: "Knowing's easy. Everyone does that ad nauseum. I just hope."
Debit: the Great One is only seen as a large claw groping the surface. And the Wasting is never explained. Still, a steady story in the trilogy.
Warrior's Gate: The TARDIS lands at Zero Point, the intersection between N- and E-Space, which is white nothingness (q.v. The Mind Robber). They run into a privateer named Rorvik, who has a ship carrying time-sensitive slaves, Tharils, "leonine mesomorphs" as described by Romana.
There is a wonderful surrealness of the Doctor walking through the black and white photos and drawings that is the link to the Tharil past. And the concept of a rapidly contracting dimension leading up to a mathematical disappearance is a novel concept. Episode 3's cliffhanger is effective, as the past quickly becomes the present, and the Doctor, surrounded by Tharils at the banquet table in one instant, suddenly finds himself surrounded by Rorvik and his crew.
There is snappy dialogue throughout. Lane: "There's a hole that you can climb through. Matter of fact, I just did." Or the Doctor: "We'll burn that bridge when we come to it." When Rorvik orders Romana hooked up, Packard, wondering of her abilities, says: "If she isn't time sensitive, she'll burnt to a frazzle." Lane: "That's how you tell." And Aldo and Royce are cariacatured union employees, lazy and apathetic, who don't care about bonuses being lost since they're on the "all out contract." And Biroc's defense to their enslavement of and later, by humans: "The weak enslave themselves." He also says that "the universe is our garden."
Errors are K-9's ears disappearing and reappearing in the first two episodes, and the Gundan Robot's axe falling on the Doctor's back without any injury to him.
This is the first of John Nathan-Turner's transitional trilogies. Adric is introduced, and the Second Romana and K9 Mark II are phased out. There would be a succeeding trilogy, also transitional, which would affect the Doctor personally.
4.0 out of 5 stars Uneven, but with Plenty of High Points,
Like much of Tom Baker's latter years in the role of the Doctor, these three serials tend to operate in fits and starts. Writers and directors sometimes seem unsure of themselves and don't know what to do with the wisecracking Doctor in the face of powerfully malevolent enemies. However, the high points more than make up for the shortcomings.
Tom Baker's Doctor and Lalla Ward's Romana are the ultimate gypsy Bohemian couple, travelling the countryside in a souped-up RV with their dog and minimal responsibilities. Their on-screen chemistry is flawless, and they're a cute couple besides. These serials also introduce the character of Adric, who was probably well conceived in the story meetings prior to his introduction. The character is hampered, however, by the ho-hum acting of the very young and inexperienced Matthew Waterhouse, whose screen career ended after only one other role.
The first episode, "Full Circle," features the TARDIS crew getting stranded in a pocket universe, E-Space. The story provides the characters the chance to get oriented to the setting and introduces Adric. The most organic and free-standing of the three serials, this is easily the strongest in the boxed set.
Second is "State of Decay," in which the characters leap to another planet and tangle with vampires. Every supporting character, especially the vampires and Adric, are saddled with stock poses and forced line readings that don't bear out. Set design and limited location work create a good atmospheric feel, but as for story and execution, this is easily the weakest episode in the set.
Finally, "Warriors' Gate" plays off the whole stranded motif, placing the characters at the juncture of the two universes. As this was Lalla Ward's final episode, a big, dramatic sendoff was devised for her. Unfortunately, until close on to the end, the best dramatic scenes are reserved for the Doctor, while Adric and Romana do filler material through the middle of the story. Though an enjoyable story, it's not the strongest possible finale for as beloved a character as Romana.
Incidentally, on the early Warner Brothers tapes of this box set, some tapes of "Warrior's Gate" were mixed to VHS with bad color balance. No matter what you do, most of the serial looks as though it was shot under triple-bright klieg lights, and the colors look washed out. Though the tape is still watchable for its story, the picture is sometimes kind of hard to look at.
These episodes are as enjoyable as most of the rest of the Tom Baker years, which many Americans, including this reviewer, regard as the high point of the series. Well worth the time and money for any fan, any viewer will enjoy them immensely.
4.0 out of 5 stars Very familiar with this,
The eighteenth season of Dr. Who is the best of all Dr. Who in my personal opinion. What more could you want, Tom Baker and Lalla Ward perfect chemistry as the Doctor and Romana and K9 played by John Leeson. I have watched State of Decay(E-space story2) so many times I have it memorized. I first watched it when I was 8 or ten or something(when it was actually broadcast. Then in High school I recorded it on a low-quality VCR. It is still enchanting to watch. And now I have the other two stories after a ten year agonizing wait. Warrior's Gate is also good and very surreal. These are what Sci-fi stories should be. Shows like State of Decay and Warrior's Gate are more than just rocketships and ray guns. Seemingly 'fantasy' elements have a science to them as well. Tom Baker has always tried to be involved in the scripts and it shows in all of his work. These are his more serious shows but they continue to have the light humor of Tom Baker's Doctor injected into them. A good balance. You want to be really serious try Peter Davison, a bit too much so for my taste though. Tom Baker is many things in the E-Space Trilogy, not just silly like in previous seasons. But there is that as well if you like that.
5.0 out of 5 stars "We're adrift in E-space...!",
It was a great idea to release these three stories together, and it's a shame that the same wasn't done with the "Turlough's Treachery Trilogy" (Mawdryn Undead, Terminus & Enlightenment). "E-Space" introduces Adric (Matthew Waterhouse), whose presence makes a welcome change from the traditional inane female companion...though the actor isn't very good.
Great stories in general, and well paced. Of special note, for me at least, is the third story "Warriors' Gate", a spookily surreal escapade through non-ordinary reality that almost defies description. Another good thing about this one is that the series FINALLY loses K9...although we do find after a while that Adric isn't really all that much better. Romana's leaving scene is almost romantic in its surprise and haste, with the Doctor, aghast, ordering her to stay aboard and finally wishing her good luck with an enthusiastic, if wistful, thumbs up.
5.0 out of 5 stars Excellent!!,
This review is from: Doctor Who: The E-Space Trilogy (Full Circle / State of Decay / Warriors' Gate) (DVD)
I can't wait for this to be released. 3 great Tom Baker stories for 1 great price. Although, I love all 3 of these stories, I am most looking forward to Warriors' Gate. This excellent story is the absolute peak of Season 18 and a total joy to watch. Great performances all round and a great script....and a nicely understated swan song for Romana and K9......ahh they don't make'em like this anymore.
Most Helpful First | Newest First
Doctor Who: The E-Space Trilogy (Full Circle / State of Decay / Warriors' Gate) by Paul Joyce (DVD - 2009)