Customer Reviews

Che: A revolutionary Life - Part 1: Argentine

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

A true masterpiece. This is one of those movies that isn't appreciated upon its release, but is later seen for what it is: an amazing piece of filmmaking, featuring an amazing performance by Del Toro.

Amazing movie , you will 100% need to have part 2 so if your thinking of getting this one order them both at the same time :)

Steven Sodenberg's CHE is probably the most ambitious biopic ever, with over four hours runtime.
PART 1: The ARGENTINE follows Castro and Guevara Cuban revolutionary war against Bastista's dictature. Doing flash back and foward between the war and Guevara's trip to NY for a UN assembly, the film is fascinating.
PART 2: GUERILLA show the unsuccessful Bolivian revolution campain of Guevara, always keeping the viewer in the life of the revolution soldiers.

At the end, part 1 show the rise of EL CHE and part 2 is fall.
Personnaly, the first half is better than the second one. The first got more rhythm than the other one, but it as to be taken as ONE and only film, even if both part get a different treatment visually and narratively.

Over all, what make it a masterpiece is that the film doesn't pass a judgement on the man. It forget the myth and all the controversy around it. The film show the man. It allow the viewer to make is own opinion of Ernesto Che Guevara.

Steven Soderbergh created one of those movies that is lucky to have been made at all -- a four-hour-plus biopic of Cuban revolutionary Che Guevara.

But like most biographical movies, it's something of a mixed bag. Visually atmosphere and low-key in style, the two halves of "Che" focus on pivotal slices of Guevara's life, with an amazing lead performance by Benicio Del Toro as the titular revolutionary. Unfortunately, it's also a very slow-moving affair that brushes past some of the more unsavory facets of Che Guevara's life and personality... and ironically many of the positive ones.

Part 1: In the 1960s, Guevara (Benicio Del Toro) is in New York City for a UN conference, being interviewed by a US reporter about his viewpoints as a guerilla leader and revolutionary. Then the narrative jumps back a decade to when he and others (including Fidel Castro) consider the many injustices over in Cuba and start planning for a revolution. Despite being Argentinian by birth, Che follows them to Cuba and joins the guerilla revolution.

But despite his start as a medic, Che began showing talents in other areas, and becomes a leader of the guerilla outlaws in the Cuban countryside. He grapples with his own ill health (asthma), the loss of his compatriots and the attacks from the military, which also threaten some of the non-revolutionaries -- and as time goes on, their revolution gained power and notice, and began the ultimate battle for control of Cuba.

Part 2: Later in life, Guevera comes to Bolivia disguised as a bespectacled bald businessman, with the intent of fighting another revolution in that country. But this revolution doesn't go as well as the Cuban one (for Che): shortages in food, internal betrayal, and one of their contacts (Franka Potente) goofs up royally. As Guevera's health deteriorates, the Bolivian army and the CIA take measures to quash his guerilla forces...

Rather than the usual biographical movie format, Steven Soderbergh approaches "Che" as if he were filming a documentary. There are no scenes of little Che being kicked by a rich guy or melodramatic subplots -- it's quite literally a slice of the pivotal point of Che Guevara's life, and a 1960s shakycam interview adds to that feeling. As an added note of authenticity, almost all of the dialogue is in Spanish rather than poorly-accented English, giving a you-are-there feel.

The storyline is rather slow, speeding up gradually as the revolution really heats up... only to slow back down in the second half with Guevera's decline. Most of the story is devoted to the guerillas staggering through the countryside, living in rough shacks and campsites. Even the landscapes reflect the ascent and descent of Guevera's power -- the first half is crammed with lush, vibrant jungle life, and the second is a washed-out, grey expanse of scrubby brush. Unfortunately, this means that over four hours, the story often drags like a ripped parachute.

But despite the slowness, each movie climaxes with some revolutionary action. Pinging gunshots, explosions, tanks, tense chases through deserted streets and burning trains all play a part in the harrowing finales of each half, which are all the worst because you know that all this mayhem actually took place.

Del Toro is, to put it mildly, astonishing as Guevara -- not only is he a dead ringer physically (with the right facial hair and clothes), but he exudes a quiet charisma, literate intelligence and power that make you see exactly why someone might follow him if they agreed with his politics. No one else in the story really gets to stand out, but Del Toro simply IS the cast all by himself.

Yet ironically it's a piously bland, virtuous portrait of Guevera. Soderbergh wimps out on the cruel, extremist sides of his personality and the regime he helped create; on the other hand, he also brushes over the man's fierce intellect, his writing, and world interests. It feels like we're looking at one mirrored facet of a very complex man, and surely more of who he was -- the good, the bad AND the ugly -- could have been included.

It's obvious Soderbergh put a lot of heart into producing the raw, realistic "Che," but his glorification and simplication of a controversial figure drags down his labor of love.

I found Sodenbergh's "Che" to be a disappointment for what it didn't cover about the man's life as a revolutionary in search of a world revolution. While the actor Del Toro, as Che himself, certainly looks the part, his performance is average at best, I saw only glimpses of the dark and ugly side of Guevara's revolutionary ambition and fanaticism come through in his actions. Guevara's working relationship with Castro is signficantly underdone, leaving the viewer to wonder what real chemistry, if any, existed between Fidel the Marxist pragmatist and Guevara the Trotskyite internationalist. Certainly, as the film clearly describes, Guevara gradually became an important military figure in the overthrow of the Batista regime and the eventual success of the Cuban Revolution, but I am not sure with how much of Castro's active blessing or by how much of his own initiative. While all those original newsreel interludes in the film allow Guevera to chronicle the revolutionary path he took get to the pinnacle of power in 1960 when he stood before the world with a declaration of liberation for the world's oppressed, I am left wondering how accurate his version of events really is. The obvious friction between the Castro and Guevara's agendas, alluded to briefly in this drama documentary, does not get the real attention it deserves. Too much focus on Guevara's strengths and not enough on his weaknesses such as his inability to compromise or seek advice. If Sodenbergh was in such an experimenting mood, why didn't he include a few other public impressions on the man's public stature? He had to have detractors within the Cuban camp for Castro to limit his rise to power in the late fifties. For that reason, Part II becomes a bit of a disconnect where Guevara mysteriously disappears into the revolutionary night only to re-emerge months later in Bolivia as some self-proclaimed liberator of the world's poor. The man's failure to follow through on his big plan to overthrow the capitalist order proves how much of a loose cannon he always was in the Cuban Revolutionary movement and why perhaps Castro was always baffled as to how to rein in his political impulses. The life and times of Che Guevara is better presented in book form than as a feature-length movie because of the need to deal more intensely with the unanswered questions surrounding Che's enigmatic life. All this film did was skirt the critical issues while highlighting some of the more sensational moments in Guevara's life, albeit in a superficial fashion.

Che, pt 1 & pt 2 with Benicio Del Toro are both beautifully filmed with solid performances by all the leads, but somehow they managed to make the life & death of Che Guevara a monumental yawn-fest. The period in Cuba where Che was so influential with Fidel drags on & on with the rebels hiking through the hills with very few action scenes & the fall of Batista little more then a footnote to the story. Del Toro is a wonderful actor who was a driving force getting this film made, but he should have insisted upon tons less rhetoric and a little more action. Thank God I rented it as It would have no permanent place in my collection.

What is going on with amazon.ca ???

my preorder is locked now that they are preparing to ship this dvd to me ... and that's normal ...

but i then JUST received an eflyer from one of the big stores in downtown toronto, and they are releasing 'che' for 26.99 !!!!

i pre-ordered this for 36.99

HOW can this BE ? how can this other store afford to do this ? or WHY is amazon jacking up the price ?

what KIND of preorder deal or whatever is THIS ?

it used to be that the whole idea of preordering was to get a REAL GOOD deal .... now it just seems they 'fleece' you, and make you pay a PREMIUM to get something when it's released ....

people are better off, waiting ....... cause inevitably ...... the prices ALWAYS go down now ....