Customer Reviews


62 Reviews
5 star:
 (50)
4 star:
 (5)
3 star:
 (3)
2 star:
 (3)
1 star:
 (1)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 

The most helpful favourable review
The most helpful critical review


5.0 out of 5 stars A must see classic movie with Bogie
The Treasure of the Sierra Madre is a classic movie that has to be watched by movie fans. Set in Mexico in 1926, the movie tells the story of two down and out Americans who have nothing to their name except their meager salaries. The two men, Dobbs and Curtin, decide to team up with a weathered, old prospector, Howard, to go prospecting for gold in the mountains of...
Published on June 29 2004 by T O'Brien

versus
3.0 out of 5 stars GRIPPING DRAMA, WONDERFUL TRANSFER!
"The Treasure of Sierra Madre" is a story of greed, deception, murder and adventure - and that's just for starters. It stars Humphrey Bogart as Fred Dobbs, a reprobate who eschews the work ethic at every turn for a handout or the prospect of getting rich quick. Naturally, a prospect from an old codger, Howard (Walter Huston) - that Dobbs and another greed driven...
Published on Sept. 30 2003 by Nix Pix


‹ Previous | 1 27 | Next ›
Most Helpful First | Newest First

5.0 out of 5 stars A must see classic movie with Bogie, June 29 2004
By 
T O'Brien (Chicago, Il United States) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
The Treasure of the Sierra Madre is a classic movie that has to be watched by movie fans. Set in Mexico in 1926, the movie tells the story of two down and out Americans who have nothing to their name except their meager salaries. The two men, Dobbs and Curtin, decide to team up with a weathered, old prospector, Howard, to go prospecting for gold in the mountains of southern Mexico. Soon enough, the trio happens upon a mountain just full of gold waiting to be found. What follows is a condmenation of human greed and want of unlimited wealth and riches. The three men become suspicious of each other immediately, thinking that the other two might steal their share of the gold. At the same time, the three must deal with bandits who will stop at nothing to get their possessions. The ending does provide for a brief message of hope. Everything from the cinematography to the acting to the writing is great in this movie. Movie fans everywhere should see this classic movie.
Humphrey Bogart gives an excellent performance as Fred C. Dobbs, a wayward American who believes that the power of gold would never make him change his ways and beliefs. Watching Dobbs morph into a money hungry, paranoid man is frightening. Walter Huston, father of director John Huston, plays Howard, the grizzled old prospector who is the only calm one in the group. Tim Holt stars as Bob Curtin, Dobbs' partner and the moral leader of the trio. The movie also stars Bruce Bennett, Barton MacLane, Alfonso Bedoya, and Manuel Donde. Also look for a brief appearance from John Huston as a well-to-do American who gives Dobbs some money for a meal. The 2-Disc Special Edition offers a ton of great extras. If you're a fan of this classic movie, you will love these extras. For a classic movie, ranked #30 in the AFI Top 100, with great performances, an excellent script, and beautiful scenery, check out The Treasure of the Sierra Madre!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars One of the two greatest films ever made about pure greed, Jan. 31 2004
By 
Robert Moore (Chicago, IL USA) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
Along with the great Erich von Stroheim classic GREED (which tragically exists only in a greatly abridged version, and which was based on the haunting Frank Norris novel MCTEAGUE), this is the most powerful movie ever made on the destructive power of greed.
THE TREASURE OF SIERRA MADRE is rightfully considered one of the greatest American films, and is also yet another in a string of first-rate collaborations between John Huston and Humphrey Bogart. Although Bogart made many superb films in the forties and fifties, a disproportionate number were with Huston, including the film that made him a star, THE MALTESE FALCON, and the film that garnered Bogie his only Oscar, THE AFRICAN QUEEN.
The cast consists primarily of three drifters who want to hit it rich in Mexico. Bogart plays Fred C. Dobbs, in one of the greatest roles of his career. The character of Bob Curtin is played by Tim Holt, a "B" actor (in the quite literal sense of having acted in scores of "B" pictures) who nonetheless managed to get parts in some exceptionally great films, notably this one, THE MAGNIFICENT AMBERSONS, and MY DARLING CLEMENTINE, as well as a small role in STAGECOACH (he plays the cavalry commander who rides a short distance with the stagecoach before departing). Both Bogart and Holt are excellent, but the film is more or less stolen by the great Walter Huston, John's father, in the last great role in a long and distinguished career as the veteran prospector Howard.
The film was based on a very great novel by the same title by one of the most reclusive authors in the history of literature. During his lifetime, the identify of B. Traven was unknown. If you find dust jackets for printings of his novels from the forties and fifties and sixties, the biographical details are something out of science fiction. Some even claimed that he was Jack London, living in Mexico after having faked his own death! Eventually, investigators went to Mexico after his death and searched exhaustively for the secrets to his identity. He turned out to be an ex-patriot German (not a surprise, since his books were always published in Germany before the United States) named Rex Marut. When John Huston went down to Mexico to film THE TREASURE OF SIERRA MADRE, he attempted to arrange a meeting with B. Traven, but was informed that he was to meet with Traven's representative Hal Croves instead. There is a wonderful photograph that exists of John Huston and "Hal Groves" talking. As he talked with Croves, Huston began to suspect that he was in fact B. Traven himself, though he was unable to voice his suspicion. Years later, it was confirmed to Huston that Hal Groves was yet another alias for Ret Marut a.k.a. B. Traven. Given this fascinating story, it would have been wonder if they could have included as one of the extras for the DVD set the 60-minute documentary THE MAN WHO WAS B. TRAVEN. The extras are good, but this would have been a wonderful addition.
Filming THE TREASURE OF SIERRA MADRE in 1948 was a fascinating choice by John Huston. In 1947, when they were filming, a sharp shift to the political right was clearly discernable. Whereas Hollywood in the 1930s had been largely leftist, in the late forties it was unquestionably right wing. Among directors especially, there were virtually no exceptions, though two prominent directors persisted in their leftist beliefs: one was the great Billy Wilder and the other was John Huston. B. Traven himself was a liberal anarchist populist (it is widely thought he was self-exiled in Mexico because of previous political activity), and the book, as does the movie, is an attack on the materialist values driving Western civilization. Not many directors would have had the courage in 1947 (it was released in January 1948) to make a movie about the evils of greed, but Huston was one who did. Likewise, Bogart was one of the more politically liberal actors in Hollywood, and was unafraid of being in a movie with the message that this one contained.
The film is highly unusual in having been filmed primarily on location in Mexico, unlike most Hollywood films, which would merely film in some southern California location. This imparts a look to the film that sets it apart fromAlso unlike most Hollywood films, Huston actually employed Hispanic actors in Hispanic roles. This allowed one veteran Mexican character actor, Alfonso Bedoya, to deliver one of the most famous lines in the history of the movies, when he tells Fred C. Dobbs, "Badges? We don't need no stinking badges!"
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars A BONA-FIDE CLASSIC STORY OF GREED AND BETRAYAL !, Dec 27 2003
By 
Paulo Leite (Lisbon, Portugal) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
Here you have a trully great package: a top director (John Huston) and a top star (Bogart) with an great screenplay, music (by Max Steiner), great photography (by Ted McCord) and a top cast. The story revolves around a group of stray losers (stranded in a mexican town) who decide to join forces and go after the (gold) riches of the wild, lawless mexican lands. They are greedy Dobbs (Bogart), honest Curtin (Tim Holt) and wise old Howard (Walter Huston). But the gold fortune they gain from the mountain soon transforms their views and relationships as Dobbs quickly falls into paranoia.
This is a trully classic film which deserved a trully great DVD edition... and this is it!! A two-disc edition with everything you can dream of... A great documentary (The Story of TTOTSM) with Martin Scorsese (lots of and others), another documentary about John Huston, two great Bugs Bunny films (one is a funny spoof of this film), A Lux Radio Theater broadcast, a vast gallery of photos and publicity material, a dozen Bogart trailers, one short film, a newsreel... everything you need to reproduce a classic night at the movies back in 1948!!!!!!
Obviously, the film in this edition has flawless sound and image... and along with this incredible tray of extras, this is surely the DVD edition to buy.
It seems that Warner Home Video is commited to release deffinitive editions of some of its classics (Thanks, WHV!!). I bought this DVD in a box that contains also Yankee Doodle Dandy and The Adventures of Robin Hood (two other two-disc editions who got this first rate treatment).
A great buy for an affordable price! Check for the 3 film box containing The Treasure of the Sierra Madre, Yankee Dodle Dandy and The Adventures of Robin Hood.
John Huston appears briefly (and repeatedly) as the american in a white suit who gives Bogart a coin - surely, the greatest director-cameo I've ever seen in an american classic film.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars Bogart's greatest performance, Dec 25 2003
By 
David M. Lovin (Willow Spring, NC United States) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
Treasure of Sierra Madre features Humphrey Bogart at his very best. As down and out Fred Dobbs, he spends his days hitting up others for money, (Hey mister, can you stake a fellow American to a meal?) He is so fixated on the money in the people's hands, that he doesn't even see their faces. He hits up the same man in the same suit three different times for meal money.
Eventually, he hears an old grizzled prospector (Walter Huston)talk about the riches available to them in the mountains in the form of gold. The old man had a desire to go back if he could find a couple of younger men who would like to go. Along with Tim Holt, Bogart and the older man head for the hills in search of wealth.
Even before they get there, the old man has warned the younger men about the dangers of finding a lot of gold. Their hearts will turn greedy and wicked, he said. Bogart says that once he got a few thousand dollars worth, that would be enough for him. The beauty of the film is the simple irony of that statement. Bogart's transformation into the obsessive, gold loving man he becomes is amazing. He can trust no one, even the two men he is partnered with.
During their time in the hills, they encounter several memorable characters who are all trying to either kill them, steal their gold, or both. At least that's the way Dobbs looks at them. Most notable is the bandito Alfonso Bedoya who does not say "We don't need no stinkin badges", rather "I don't have to show you any stinkin badges". This, like Casablanca's "Play it again, Sam" is one of the most missed quotes in movie history.
The ending of the film is both logical and tragic. In the end, all we can say is that Bogart's character is one of the most interesting character studies we have witnessed on film. We are left to ask if something like that could really happen to us. Could we become this focused on something and forsake all that is so important to us? According to this film, it's very possible.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars A Must-Have DVD, Dec 6 2003
By 
J. Remington "John Remington" (Adams, Oregon USA) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
Since I have already reviewed this, one of America's greatest cinematic masterpieces, I will urge any and all to purchase this excellent packaging and presentation of John Huston's finest fictional hour (his war-time documentaries are his truest masterpieces).
Besides containing a pristine and vibrant transfer which makes the gorgeous silver, rainy-grey, cloud-white and jet black cinematography vibrate with rich detail, Warner Brothers has outdone themselves and bookended this classic film with a treasure trove of fantastic extras.
While the commentary by author Eric Lax is only so-so, the documentaries are brilliant and illumanitive- especially the biographical feature which alone makes this package a must have. Featuring interviews with the avuncular Huston himself as well has film clips and wonderful insights from his family and co-workers, this superb documentary celebrates one of Hollywood's true characters. Huston was a type of figure never to be seen again.
The behind the scenes documentary about the dramatic story behind the making of the film, narrated by John Milius (I would have appreciated his commentary more!)proves almost as entertaining as the feature itself. Short Subjects, Cartoons and trailers as well as a fascinating radio broadcast from 1949 featuring Bogie and Walter Huston rounds out the extras which make this a most certain must have DVD for all film fans.
Money well spent!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars Grab this one while you can, Dec 1 2003
By 
Ian Muldoon (Coffs Harbour, NSW Australia) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
Movie lovers have waited many years for the kind of presentation offered in this outstanding reissue. Some may consider the feature story a cynical depiction of warped Western values. However, it does give a very sympathetic portrait of the Mexican people whereas they have often been depicted in cinema as uncivilized beasts. As depicted by B. Traven we learn of the honesty of the young mexican lottery ticket seller even after he had been verbally and physically humiliated by Fred C. Dobbs, we learn of their satisfactory dispensation of justice to three Mexican thieves and murderers, and we learn of their reverence for knowledge. Secondly, the film shows an early example of environmental responsibility when the old man insists on "repairing" the mountain after the trio have mined it. Thirdly, Mr Bogart gives one of his most devastating over the top performances as a truly nasty character who gets a thoroughly deserved come-uppance when clubbed to death. The film could be viewed as the allegory of the three archetypal characters - the good, the bad, and the innocent, or the three sides to every man. And there is an undoubtedly great cinematic moment at the conclusion when the old man(the good) and the young man(the innocent) laugh almost to the point of pain at the fact the gold dust has been swept up by the wind and "returned to the mountain" where it belongs. Humanity, love, and civilisation prevail in the end. The print quality is excellent. But in addition to this the program may be viewed as one would see it when released - a contemporary newsreel, trailer for another film, a cartoon precede the "main feature". The real "gold" in the extras though, is a feature length documentary on the director John Huston, narrated by Robert Mitchum and featuring Lauren Bacall, Paul Newman and others. The clips from some of Mr Huston's war documentaries, especially those associated with the US army landing in Italy must be some of the best war footage ever captured on film but remained classified by the US Army until 1980.
The discussion on courage, as understood by Mr Huston, is astonishing and memorable. A remarkable documentary filled with many film clips including Mr Huston's private collection. To me, this edition represents astonishing value for any film lover.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars Treasure hunt in mexican desert, Nov. 16 2003
By A Customer
Timeless tale of greed and desire, as three down-and- out men track down elusive golden wealth.
The movie is set up extremely well, as we learn about the men and their lot in life, well before they set out on their dangerous quest.
The parallels of greed resound today, with the corporate scandals and such. The riches that tempt men's souls can destroy the weak. Management techniques of the trio are on display as well, as they face challenges in the bleak wilderness.
The movie really holds up well under 21st century scrutiny. Every scene has meaning and their are many, running sub-plots and themes that remain true to themselves as they interweave,leave and then return throughout the movie. Keep your eye on the young Robert Blake, he had a small but amusing role in the beginning.
There are not many movies that have as much to offer, scene after scene, as this one does. Those who speak spanish will enjoy some of the un-translated dialogue between various locals, it is not spoon fed with accented english as so many movies do today. Great stuff!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars AFI top 100/ WB Classic now on digitally remastered DVD set!, Oct. 25 2003
By 
forrie (Nashua, NH United States) - See all my reviews
The American Film Institute's (AFI)1998 Top 100 American Movies in the first 100 years placed "The Treasure of the Sierra Madre" at #30. This 1947 western classic was one of Warner Brothers (WB) Studios many Classic movies produced in the 1930's &40's. (ie, Adventures of Robin Hood (1938), Casablanca (1942), Yankee Doodle Dandy to name a few). The WB had a stable of Stars like; Bogart, Cagney, Flynn, Bergman, Barrymore, Rains, Bacall, Greenstreet, Lorre & De Haviland to name a few which produced an abundance of classics in short order.
Well for the first time WB has meticulously digitally remastered their classics of old under the DVD "Two Disc Special Edition" Series. These DVD's are outstanding and the Feature Film is worth the price of admission alone, but Warner Brothers has provided us a 2 DVD set with everything for us to escape to 1947 Hollywood and relive the movie theatre experience. DISC 1 - Provides us with a "Night at the Movies" (circa 1947) This is pure genius (hats off to the WB) and the viewer experiences a complete show (so get the popcorn ready, this is fun stuff!!!!) To begin Leonard Maltin gives us an introduction to this 1947 show followed by coming attractions, a newsreel, a cartoon, a short subject film and then the Feature film all back to back just like the movies. AWESOME. Also on Disc 1 are 12 Humphrey Bogart film trailers. Thats just the first disc!!! DISC 2 - Has a 2 hour documentary on the life of Director John Huston (2 Oscar's, Direction & Screen Play for "The Treasure of Sierra Madre"), Documentary on "Discovering the Treasure of.....", Classic Bugs Bunny Cartoon, Storyboards, Cast & Crew, Publicity Materials Gallery and a 1949 Radio broadcast starring Bogart & Walter Huston (Oscar winner for best supporting in Treasure (also John Hustons father)).
Warner Brothers did a fabulous job digitally transferring (the picture & sound are perfect)this Full Screen Black & White feature to DVD and there's more classic movies to come. I can't wait. This a must have for your home theatre experience. Enjoy.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars Widescreen complaints invalid, Oct. 13 2003
By 
Karl Fast - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
One customer review gave this DVD a mere four stars, calling it "visually abbreviated" because it isn't in widescreen.
There was no such thing as widescreen prior to 1953. ALL films made before then were filmed with an aspect ratio of 1.33:1 (aka 4:3), the same as television. In fact, the size of your television screen was taken from the standard format defined by Hollywood.
In 1953, "The Robe" became the first picture released in Cinemascope. This is considered the birth of widescreen. "The Robe" was a huge popular success. (It is true that there were some widescreen films prior to "The Robe," but the number of these films was extremely small and required theatres to use special equipment.)
You can get all the the gory details at the Widescreen Museum: http://www.widescreenmuseum.com/
This DVD of "Treasure of the Sierra Madre" is not "visually abbreviated" in any way. There is nothing to abbreviate.
So don't go looking for widescreen versions of "Citizen Kane" or "The Wizard of Oz."
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


3.0 out of 5 stars GRIPPING DRAMA, WONDERFUL TRANSFER!, Sept. 30 2003
By 
Nix Pix (Windsor, Ontario, Canada) - See all my reviews
"The Treasure of Sierra Madre" is a story of greed, deception, murder and adventure - and that's just for starters. It stars Humphrey Bogart as Fred Dobbs, a reprobate who eschews the work ethic at every turn for a handout or the prospect of getting rich quick. Naturally, a prospect from an old codger, Howard (Walter Huston) - that Dobbs and another greed driven young hopeful, Bob Curtin (Tim Holt) steak out their claim for gold in the mountains - suddenly appeals to Fred's cynical quest for untold wealth. But the journey to rich rewards is marred by Fred's paranoia that everyone is trying to steal from him. This fear ultimately leads Fred to mistrust both his compatriots and actually attempt to kill Bob in the middle of the desert. The betrayal backfires for all those involved with the treasure remaining an elusive mirage that none of the principle players ever get their hands on. John Huston masterfully directs and costars in a cameo, in this masterful, gritty and thrilling action/adventure/drama!
Warner's gives us a cleaned up but very inconsistent transfer. There are a few problems worth noting, including aliasing and shimmering of fine details that crops up and detract from the visual presentation. There's also a bit of pixelization and some edge enhancement. The gray scale has been nicely balanced. Fine details are beautifully rendered. You won't believe this film is over 60 years old! One aside: approximately two thirds into the film, at the point where Fred almost kills Bob in the desert, the image quality suddenly spirals into a third generation looking print quality that is totally out of sync with the rest of the video presentation. There's an incredible amount of excessive film grain and age related artifacts. This poor video quality is never explained on either the film's audio commentary track or the documentary that is included on the making of the film so I, in turn, am at a total loss to explain it myself. At best I have to assume that no first generation print master was available for this portion of the film, hence other film sources were considered and ultimately utilized to make the film whole again. The audio is mono but well balanced.
Extras include documentaries on both the film and the career of John Huston, featurettes, audio commentaries, trailers and a stills gallery. Very handsomely mounted and very thoughtfully put together. My hat off to the good people at Warner Brothers!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


‹ Previous | 1 27 | Next ›
Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Treasure of the Sierra Madre [Blu-ray] (Bilingual)
CDN$ 19.99 CDN$ 16.99
In Stock
Add to cart Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews