Customer Reviews

Doctor Who: The Android Invasion

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(3)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This Tom Baker story is the odd one out in a season widely regarded as one of Doctor Who's best. The middle of Philip Hinchcliffe's reign as producer, the 13th season is filled with memorable sci-fi tales with healthy doses of suspense and horror. In contrast, "The Android Invasion" is the most straightforward adventure, without any real finesse, making it stand out like the proverbial sore thumb. It is certainly not a bad story - but on the other hand, it is not spectacular. It is a standard alien invasion of Earth story, with a plot that doesn't challenge or enthrall. It is basically a rip-off of "Invasion of the Body Snatchers" (although the rest of the season's stories were similar rip-offs of classic tales, but more stylishly done) and is very predictable, with a few gaping plotholes. However, while all I have written so far indicates that I loathe the story, in actual fact I have a soft spot for it. It was one of the first stories I saw, 21 years ago (my, how time flies) and some scenes rest vividly in my mind. The androids shooting bullets out of their fingers; Sarah Jane's face falling off to reveal the android; the deserted village; the incredibly ugly (but well designed) Kraals. These aspects always made repeat viewings welcome. There are other positive elements to the story: the location work, especially in and around the village, is excellent and the direction (by former producer Barry Letts) is very good. UNIT allies Harry Sullivan and RSM Benton make their swansong Doctor Who appearances, while Martin Friend's Styggron is also well portrayed. Unfortunately I cannot say the same for Milton Johns' Guy Crayford - any role Johns has played in the programme (Benik in "The Enemy of the World" and Kelner in "The Invasion of Time" are the other two I can recall) are especially camp - this performance is no exception, giving an irritating edge to what is essentially an interesting and sympathetic character (surely he must have known his eye wasn't missing, either! - another piece of credibility stretching). The final episode is also a rather boring runaround, with a routine ending and effects that are less than spectacular (quite run of the mill for Doctor Who, but the "android freezing" scenes are cringeworthy!) However, in a certain context, with a strong measure of nostalgia and a not too serious countenance, "The Android Invasion" can be enjoyed.

As others have pointed out this is rather a standard android invasion type story with worked in rehashed pulp science fiction props and plots.

Having said that it is more of a comic horror type of story with Tom Baker literally hamming it up throughout. From the early moaning and groaning from Sarah Jane (are we there yet, are we there yet Type of complaining about getting back home) to the Marie celeste type village - could be in Epcot - through to the twisted Sontaran type aliens there is a lot of tongue in cheek humour. This also is a bit of a prototype of the later, not as good, Peter Davison story 'Four to Doomsady' which has a number of similarities but not as good sets or location.

This story is quite droll and if it was to be taken too seriously then I must admit it would not be such a good tale. I have not seen such a Doctor Who where Tom Baker is in such good comic form. It reminds me of a later UK tv show where he played a house doctor and obviously had a lot of fun doing it.

Do not judge this story too harshly. Given the context of the other stories of the season and the Tom Baker series it would not be terribly logical to broadcast a dummy.

Watch it in lightheart and you will get much enjoyment from it.
Originally broadcast 22 November to 13 December 1975.

When Sarah Jane asks the Doctor if they are on Earth, the Doctor answers "possibly." Part of this has to do with the high radiation reading he gets from an instrument.

However, they see a UNIT corporal commit suicide over a cliff, and upon closer examination discover he has all newly minted coins and bills in his wallet. Upon closer examination of the village of Devesham, which Sarah recognizes, they discover it deserted. When people do appear, they do so in a robotic, clockwork fashion. Among those in the pub is none other than the corporal, alive and well! Sarah gets off a parting shot at his expense: "I don't you think you should be drinking so soon after breaking your neck."

Both decide to explore the Space Defense Station a mile from the pub, where to their bewilderment, they find their friends, Mr. Benton and Harry Sullivan, under orders to hunt them down. To add to the mystery, they are being led by Guy Crayford, an astronaut testing a new space freighter XK-5 who vanished, presumably killed by a colliding asteroid. "All our friends led by a dead man," the Doctor observes wryly. But Crayford is under the thrall of Styggron, a strange alien resembling a cross between a rhino and a boar.

The military vs scientists motif is explored as Styggron puts the emphasis on science as the thing that will help his fellow Kraals, while Marshall Chedaki insists on military might. All I can say is that if Chedaki were in charge of the operation, the Earth wouldn't stand a chance, as Styggron makes mistake after mistake. Chedaki's analysis of the Doctor as someone who has a history of supporting libertarian causes is half-accurate--I'd include a "left" in front of "libertarian."

The astronaut-suited androids with index finger guns is a revamp of the Autons, whose hands dropped down to reveal guns. At one point, the Doctor looks at a robot pointing its gun at him, and asks "Is that finger loaded?"

In the Phillip Hinchcliffe's gothic regime, this is a take on the original movie of Invasion Of The Body Snatchers, down to the black pods and duplicates, and the paranoid atmosphere that anyone could be a duplicate. Barry Letts, who was Hinchcliffe's predecessor as producer, directs this one!

Continuity errors irk me to no end, and here's one. The bogus calendar in the village reads 6 July Friday. This is a problem if one considers the UNIT and contemporary Earth stories to be set in the exact year the story was broadcast. This aired from 22 November to 13 December 1975. The closest years with the calendar structure is 1973 or 1979. It can't be 1973, as the Doctor is still in his third incarnation, and it can't be 1979, as the Brigadier has retired by then. He is still in action in this story. The only possible explanation is that the Kraals first conceived of the plan on 6 July 1973, which would fit Crayford's disappearance two years ago. OK, that's sorted out then. Whew!

There are a few good moments, such as an android Sarah's faceplate falling off to reveal circuits beneath, and the difference seen between the cold emotionless robots and the actual humans with warmth and feeling.

This is the last series appearances of John Levene (Benton) and Ian Marter (Harry), the latter having died suddenly at his home in 1986.

While owing a lot to its sci-fi roots, The Android Invasion has consistency errors, all regarding the Kraal plans and the androids. Their plan make the use of androids redundant, so why use them? Not one of the better Fourth Doctor stories.

I truly enjoy the earlier Tom Baker (Sarah Jane) episodes. "The Android Invasion" is a wonderful example (when he actually wore the hat) and a great performance by Liz Sladen as they arrive and explore a seemingly deserted English village. When I sit down to watch a Dr Who, I often find myself reaching for this tape. The story has a special charm that is difficult to explain. I would recommend that all Dr Who fans add "The Android Invasion" to their library. It is one of my very favorite episodes!

This is one of those "pretty good" stories that had the great misfortune to fall into an excellent season. The story is remarkably typical (and amazingly similar to the basic plot of "Terror of the Zygons", just three adventures earlier!), and quite a bit of the supporting acting merely average, but there -is- a nice sense of fun throughout all four episodes. Tom Baker and Lis Sladen continue to work very well together, and this leads to a number of nice moments; plus, the final appearances of John Levene and Ian Marter as Benton and Harry are nicely done. The androids themselves are well-realised (although more than a bit like the Autons from the Pertwee era), and the stunt double stuff in the final episode is fairly painless. Also, part 2 boasts a really classic cliffhanger everyone remembers!

Unfortunately, there's also a bad side. It's very regrettable that Nicholas Courtney couldn't return as the Brigadier; instead, he's been replaced with a carbon copy character played only decently by Patrick Newell of "The Avengers" fame. That's not to say the other supporting cast are anything to boast about, either...in fact, they seem to just be walking through the lines. On the design front, the Kraals' outfits are some of the worst in a long time, instantly revealing that there are perfectly human men inside them.

This is not a total loss of a story - in fact, it's good fun in many places; that doesn't make up for the fact, though, that it's very standard, and sticks out rather obviously amongst so many great stories.