Customer Review

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Revisiting the Soundgarden, Jan. 5 2011
This review is from: Telephantasm (Dlx Ed) (W/Dvd) (Audio CD)
Soundgarden was one of the first Seattle bands I tweaked onto, mainly because Soundgarden (and Alice in Chains) were the most metallic in their approach. I refused to call them grunge -- not with riffs this Sabbathy and a singer who could have been Ronnie James Dio's protege.

Soundgarden broke up 13 years ago, and Chris Cornell started (in my opinion) a lucklustre solo career, while Matt Cameron fared better as the longtime drummer in Pearl Jam. There's a certain renaissance for these kinds of bands now, what with a recent reunion album by Alice and now a Soundgarden reunion. Telephantasm acts as a sort of "Anthology" collection. Back in the 90's this deluxe edition would have been considered a boxed set. Just that in 2010 we've done away with the box! It's not quite a greatest hits set (live versions of "Jesus Christ Pose" and "Pretty Noose" are subbed into for the familiar singles), and not quite a rarities set (9 of the 24 tracks are rare or unreleased).

What Telephantasm is, is a really good overview of one of Seattle's best. From the Deep Six compilation to their final album Down on the Upside, this set chronologically presents Soundgarden at their very best, live and in the studio. Personally I haven't listened to Soundgarden in a while. I have a bunch of albums and singles at home, but after the band broke up, I reverted back to my metal roots and didn't listen to Soundgarden much. For me, this was almost like the first time again. Hearing the songs in this new context didn't take away from what they were.

Outstanding classics for me include: "Fopp", "Superunknown", "My Wave", "Dusty", "Burden In My Hand", "Rusty Cage", and "Spoonman". I mean, every fan of musicianship absolutely needs a song in their collection with a killer spoons solo.

Outstanding rarities for me were: the video mix of "Fell On Black Days", and live versions of "Pretty Noose", "Flower", "Blow Up The Outside World", and a frenetic "Jesus Christ Pose". Hard to believe that Cameron can play those complex rhythms live. Unbelievable!

Of course there is the much hyped "Black Rain", an unreleased track from the Down on the Upside sessions. Sounds great. Could have been written for Badmotorfinger. Liner notes are excellent. There are two essays, one by guitarist Kim Thayil (one of the coolest guys in rock). There are a handful of photos and exhaustive credits. I'm not too keen on the cover art, but there is a big fold out revealing the whole thing.

Of course there's the DVD, for some this will be worth the price of purchase alone! This is a pretty comprehensive collection of music videos including uncensored and international versions. For new fans who are upset that they didn't get the studio versions of "Jesus Christ Pose" or "Pretty Noose" on the CDs, they are here on the DVD.

There is a bonus track on some versions -- the unreleased song "The Telephantasm". However the best way to get that song is to buy the 7" single, which also includes a killer, killer live version of "Gun". This is a brand new live version by the reunited band. If you want the truly complete picture of Telephantasm, go out and get that single while you still can. Also required, but much more expensive and still unacquired by me: There is a bonus track on the vinyl version of the album: "Beyond the Wheel", live by the reunited band.

Lastly I'll have to say a few words about the mastering of this album. Unfortunately the Loudness Wars can add Soundgarden to its body count. The album was mastered way too loud, and it really takes its toll on the sound. You can really hear it on the cymbals. It's unfortunate since so many of these songs are previously unreleased. This is the only way you can hear them, and it's not as good as it should be, thanks to the record company mastering this damned thing too loudly.

Regardless, the music is incredible. 4 stars.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Review Details

Item

3.8 out of 5 stars (5 customer reviews)
5 star:
 (1)
4 star:
 (3)
3 star:    (0)
2 star:
 (1)
1 star:    (0)
 
 
 
Add to cart Add to wishlist
Reviewer

LeBrain
(HALL OF FAME)    (TOP 50 REVIEWER)   

Top Reviewer Ranking: 35