This review is from: Shining At The Bottom Of The Sea (Hardcover)
I don't know how anyone found this book "readable." Marche succeeds in creating three meaningful stories: "Pigeon Blackhat" (which somewhat successfully echoes Defoe),"Sufferance Row" and "The Master's Dog." Almost all other stories are uninteresting, amateurish and seem like exercises in style. Overall, I was left completely disinterested in Sanjania and its literature. The concept had so much potential...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Shining At The Bottom Of The Sea 0670066176
Stephen Marche
Viking Canada
Shining At The Bottom Of The Sea
generic
"Sanjanians" have produced some horrible writing
I don't know how anyone found this book "readable." Marche succeeds in creating three meaningful stories: "Pigeon Blackhat" (which somewhat successfully echoes Defoe),"Sufferance Row" and "The Master's Dog." Almost all other stories are uninteresting, amateurish and seem like exercises in style. Overall, I was left completely disinterested in Sanjania and its literature. The concept had so much potential...
fairy queen "fairy"
July 22 2010