This review is from: Double Decca: Handel Messiah (Audio CD)
As has been previously mentioned, this version has some notable differences from more familiar versions, my favorite being the air "He shall feed His flock/Come unto Him" which is for contralto only. The recitative "And lo, the angel of the Lord..." is somewhat longer and more arioso-like. The air "How beautiful are the feet..." is a duet for contralto and soprano, followed by a chorus. The tempi are rather brisk, which works for the most part (especially in the opening sinfonia, which is often performed excessively slowly), however the air and chorus "Oh thou that tellest good tidings" is supposed to be adante and is much closer to allegro, and the chorus "His yoke is easy" while marked allegro, is just too fast for my taste. On the whole this is a highly recommended recording, it sounds Baroque (with the orchestration and ornamentation), but it doesn't sound hollow or bland, nor does it sound like overly dramatic.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Double Decca: Handel Messiah B00000427H
Elly Ameling
Universal Music Group
Double Decca: Handel Messiah
generic
Rather Good
As has been previously mentioned, this version has some notable differences from more familiar versions, my favorite being the air "He shall feed His flock/Come unto Him" which is for contralto only. The recitative "And lo, the angel of the Lord..." is somewhat longer and more arioso-like. The air "How beautiful are the feet..." is a duet for contralto and soprano, followed by a chorus. The tempi are rather brisk, which works for the most part (especially in the opening sinfonia, which is often performed excessively slowly), however the air and chorus "Oh thou that tellest good tidings" is supposed to be adante and is much closer to allegro, and the chorus "His yoke is easy" while marked allegro, is just too fast for my taste. On the whole this is a highly recommended recording, it sounds Baroque (with the orchestration and ornamentation), but it doesn't sound hollow or bland, nor does it sound like overly dramatic.
anonymous
July 12 2004