Henri Cartier-Bresson: The Decisive Moment Hardcover – Oct 31 2014
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
No Kindle device required. Download one of the Free Kindle apps to start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, and computer.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
Reprinted to the exact specification of the original, including Henri Matisse's collage cover design, Steidl's care and craftsmanship is astounding. At 11.5" by 15," it's actually too large for my bookshelf. The spreads are sized according to the dimensions of the framelines of Cartier-Bresson's beloved Leica camera, allowing for a single large image, two vertical images, or four smaller horizontal images to fit on each spread. The sequencing is seamless and affecting-it is one of the most immersive experiences I have ever had with a book. The book's physical presence and high image quality demands not only respect for the work inside, but for it to be treated as a work of art in and of itself.--Evan Paul Laudenslager "theartblog.org "
It's immediately obvious that The Decisive Moment is a hedonistic delight, at least if your idea of hedonism is flexible enough to extend to the tactile and visual pleasure of a photography book.--Gary Cockburn "One Thousand Words "
Diligently reproduced to the finest detail, Steidl seems to have resisted the urge to over embellish the new edition with unnecessary addendums. Cartier-Bresson likely would have dismissed an elaborate reconstruction of his book as crass and egregious. The Decisive Moment is about the aesthetics of coincidence, and the faith to follow intuition. Like every brilliant unexpected moment, things can never be truly recreated, but only faithfully retold.--Krystal Grow "Wired "
With the winter months slowly waning away, what better time is there to grab a good book, a hot beverage, and lounge in bed on a chilly and blustery evening? Luckily for you, we went ahead and picked the most enticing coffee table books that will be released this month, which can be viewed in the slideshow above.--Devon Ivie "Interview "
Henri Cartier-Bresson's iconic photography book, "The Decisive Moment," has been republished, 62 years after the highly influential collection of his early work was first released.--Aurelien Breeden "The New York Times Arts Beat "
The Decisive Moment has finally been republished. Sixty-two years on, it still carries the weight of its initial importance - even if the notion of the decisive moment no longer holds sway as it once did; staged photography, conceptual strategies and digitally manipulated images have all but rendered it old-fashioned except to purists, photojournalists and street photographers.--Sean O'Hagan "The Guardian "
A decisively beautiful object that belongs in the library of anyone who cares about photography... From editing and sequencing to packaging, it's a masterpiece.--Pat Padua "Spectrum Culture "
More than ten years after his passing, the renowned street and social documentary photographer Henri Cartier-Bresson--who so famously coined the term "the decisive moment," or the second when all of the compositional elements of a scene come into harmony--continues to charm, fascinate and inspire photographers worldwide. The Decisive Moment (Steidl), Cartier-Bresson's book that was first published in 1952 by Simon and Schuster, is reentering the market. This latest edition, which will also be covered in Matisse cutouts like the original, highlights the photographer's revered early work, and it will come with a booklet of an essay on the history of The Decisive Moment by Clement Cheroux, the Centre Pompidou curator.--Libby Peterson "Rangefinder "
One of the most influential (and yet hardest to find) photobooks in print gets the Steidl gold-standard reprint treatment here. Available for the first time in sixty years, Henri Cartier-Bresson's Decisive Moment still sizzles with taut, kinetic energy. From the Matisse-designed cover through the tightly edited image selection, it's a brilliant mix of street photography and reportage, photos that, despite being perfectly composed, feel very alive. Many of them have evolved from classics to cultural wallpaper. The book reminds us of Cartier-Bresson's genius--just in case you needed a reminder.--Mark Murrmann "Mother Jones "
Within the canon of European photography books it would be difficult to find one more famous, revered and influential as Henri Cartier-Bresson's Images a la Sauvette or, as the American edition is titled, The Decisive Moment.
What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?
Top Customer Reviews
I don't think this book is worth ordering. I returned mine for a full refund. It was past the time of returning it but Amazon accepted the book back.
There is no reason to buy this book, unless you collect Cartier Bresson's books and/or you don't care about the poor quality of the photos in Steid's "The Decisive Moment".
I returned the book for four reasons:
It has far too many double spreads filled with pitfalls
The quality of printing is poor
Other books have a far better selection of Cartier Bresson's photos
I already have a few of CB's books and "The Decisive Moment" doesn't add to them.
1. Double Spreads
A double page spread in a photography book is a silly choice of design. They might look good on a magazine but definitely not on a book. They limit the view of the photograph and their large size, in the specific case of this book, make for images that are just too soft.
Even considering that Cartier Bresson's photos were naturally soft, the photos in this book, which were scanned from a sixty years old book, are certainly too soft for modern eyes. But things got worse because of the excessive enlargement of photos for double page spreads.
The worse thing about those awful double spreads is how they impoverish the original photograph.Read more ›
Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
The real issue here for many reviewers may simply a lack of familiarity with gravure reproduction. If one can get over the fact that it doesn't look like today's (truly excellent) high-end lithographic reproduction, it's possible to appreciate the subtle beauty of the result. For other examples of great gravure, see Paul Strand's La France de Profil or Robert Doisneau's La Banlieue de Paris, both of which are lovely in a way that's totally different from the printing of today's high-end photo books. Steid's version of The Americans also does a nice job of capturing the quality of the gravure first editions.
It's all a bit like arguments over whether inkjet printing looks better on matte or baryta paper. Both can be beautiful but represent different aesthetics. So don't buy this book if you don't like gravure. But if you do, or at least want an edition that is very faithful to the original, the Steidl is it.
I just took my copy out of the shrink wrap, and couldn't be more pleased. I am Thrilled with this book.
Here is some background that may be helpful. Several months ago, when I heard this book was being reprinted, I decided to see if my university's interlibrary loan service could track down a copy is the rare, valuable, original for me to borrow, to see if I wanted to buy the Steidl edition when released. I figured it was a longshot since a book this rare and valuable is risky to lend out. But the library was able to get it for me and I can tell you that Steidl did a PERFECT job reproducing it. It is literally as though you are holding a brand new copy of the original in your hands (except better, because the photos haven't faded over 50 years and had hundreds of students' hands on the pages- they look fresh as they should).
So I have to admit, I'm really baffled by the negative reviews, especially one that claims to have seen the original. If people think the photos look like copies of copies, well, that's what you would have thought of the original too. Yeah, they're not hyperglossy, but neither was the original book. End of story. It's EXACTLY what the version of the original edition I had looked like (but, again, only better: because it's new, not missing the dust jacket, and comes in a nice slipcase).
I can tell you as someone serious about photography books ( and ones from Steidl as well: I've spend lots of $ on Steidl's gorgeous editions of William Eggleston's work) and street photography itself, you should not let these negative reviews of the print quality dissuade you.
The content, of course, speaks for itself: the book is an absolute masterpiece.
So I would really advise you just see for yourself what you think. You may be disappointed if you think they will look like digital photos. But they are not now, and they never were. What they are is faithful to HCB's vision for the book.
Someone wrote: "this book is worth every penny." No. This book is worth MORE than every penny. To get it for under $100 is unimaginable. It's a fantastic book worthy of any photographer's collection.
***JUNE 2015 EDIT***
I am so thankful I ordered this book, waited six months and landed a copy in February 2015.
I took mine to a local university and compared it, side-by-side, to the original book. Steidl produced an exacting copy down to the finest detail. Aside from being in newer condition, I'd have a hard time telling the 2015 version from the 1952 version.
There are better books featuring Bresson's work. Sure. No question. But that's like saying the newest Ford Mustang is better than the 1964 1/2 Ford Mustang. "Better" being about as subjective as it gets. "The Decisive Moment" is a classic. This cannot be argued and it belongs on any photographer's bookshelf,
Now it appears to be out of print once again. Will we have to wait another 50 years for it to be printed again? If so, I have mine safely tucked away.
But I do wonder if Herr Steidl didn't meet this challenge with a bit too much desire for fidelity? In the 60 years since this book was first published the standards in both photography and graphic arts have changed dramatically. Complaints about the "poor image reproduction quality" fundamentally reflect this shift to the degree that tastes have changed. I recall the original book being printed in deep, rich photogravure. This intaglio-style process deposited copious amounts of ink on the paper to achieve the deep darks. Photogravure also had a characteristic tactility that no other process can match. But today photogravure is long gone. It was a very specialized process requiring equipment and craftsmanship that even Herr Steidl could not resurrect. He seemed to do his best with modern pressmanship techniques. Unfortunately while the results are sometimes convincing they are often anemic when compared to original photogravure. To today's photo enthusiasts weaned on over-sharpened, over-contrasted photos on social sites the images will look like they've been run through a washing machine.
What's more, the end boards curl outward like Shirley Temple's hair. I can literally slide the book out of its slip case and start a countdown from 30 to watch the top board curl like a flower opening towards the sun. That's not a terrible issue but it is a great disappointment and a surprise to see such a detail overlooked, or a corner cut, by Steidl. This was, after all, not a cheap book!
Personally, I think that Herr Steidl should have applied the full power of contemporary graphic arts technologies to this republication of The Decisive Moment. Gerhard Steidl is arguably the best printer of photobooks of our times. His skills and his legendary devotion to details are unmatched in the industry. I know that he could have produced a new TDM that would have greatly exceeded the original book's quality while remaining faithful to HCB's concept and images. But I get the impression that he may have become intimidated by the process or diverted by the doubtless many parties who must certainly have been screeching in his ears. So perhaps some fidelity to the original book's reproduction processes has produced what amounts to a photocopy of a The Decisive Moment.
So, yes, I'm rather disappointed by the results of this book particularly after waiting 6+ months on back-order here. My advice to prospective buyers: get a used copy unless you positively need it new. This edition will certainly not be a collectible edition and you should be able to find used copies for at a substantial discount shortly. If you're genuinely enchanted by the work make an effort to view an original copy of the book at a library, such as a major university or museum library. You'll be impressed.