Murmuring the Judges Hardcover – Large Print, May 2000
|New from||Used from|
|Hardcover, Large Print, May 2000||
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
No Kindle device required. Download one of the Free Kindle apps to start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, and computer.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
³A remarkably assured first novel...a tour de force.² (THE NEW YORK TIMES) for Skinner¹s Rules -- unknown --This text refers to the MP3 CD edition.
From the Publisher
These hair-trigger thrillers by Quintin Jardine, one of Scotland¹s top-selling writers, have been praised for their ingenious plotting and powerful emotional drama. With Edinburgh police chief Robert Skinner at the center of the action, they form a first-class, robustly entertaining series of police procedurals.
Also available by Quintin Jardine: Autographs in the Rain, Gallery Whispers, Thursday Legends,Skinner's Ghosts, Skinner's Rules, Skinner's Festival, Skinner's Trail, Skinner's Round, Skinner's Ordeal and Skinner's Mission.--This text refers to the MP3 CD edition. See all Product Description
Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
Well first and foremost, I'm having trouble with the chronology. In this book he's gotten back together with his second wife, and his first daughter is a practicing solicitor (British-speak for lawyer), but by the recent chronology seems to be over ten years too early.
The other thing that puzzles me: was he a good writer "out of the box" so to speak, or has he in fact failed to materially improve his craft? i.e. surprisingly little difference in the writing quality compared with his latest books. Anyway, a good yarn with a very plausible thought intricate plot, but the simplicity of his characters keeps him from being in the top drawer (I'll still continue to read him). Like Ian Rankin, I think an at least passing familiarity with Edinburgh enormously improves one's interest in his books (my son attended well to be fair to him graduated from Edinburgh University so I came to know the town reasonably well).
A minor beef, of the type that I am sure mystery writers are thoroughly sick of. BTW BOT a plot spoiler here. A key item in one scene is that a shot from a high-powered sporting rifle at only a moderate distance is not heard by anybody because they are all watching a soccer match. Obviously Mr. Jardine has never personally heard such a rifle being fired; all those who HAVE had that experience (myself, numerous times both as a firee and witness) will know that this is totally impossible. Not only is it a distinctive sound, but it is FAR louder than the noise of any sports event.
But recommended overall as my rating shows.