The Science of Superheroes Hardcover – Sep 3 2002
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
No Kindle device required. Download one of the Free Kindle apps to start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, and computer.
Getting the download link through email is temporarily not available. Please check back later.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
""...Gresh and Weinberg's wonderful little book is both a potted history of superhero comics, and a pop science manual for the extremely lazy..."" (hero.ac.uk-Higher Education and Research Opportunities, 28 October 2002)
""?children who enjoyed the Spider-Man and X-men movies will delight in The Science of Superheroes.... Perfect for turning a comic-book obsession into an enthusiasm for the laboratory...""(The Times, 7 December 2002)
""...This is definitely a fun book..."" (The Alchemist, 9 January 2003)
""...All in all I can thoroughly recommend this book to anyone with an interest in science and at least a nostalgic fondness for comics..."" (Chemistry In Britain, December 2002)
""...The Science of Superheroes could be a useful tool for encouraging comic fans to delve into science..."" (Physics World, February 2003)
"What seemed impossible just sixty years ago during the Golden Age of Comics, now appears increasingly plausible. The Science of Superheroes serves as an entertaining and informative guide to comic book wonders bound to come." —Julius Schwartz,Editor Emeritus, DC Comics
"We comics fans have known it for years, of course: somewhere, in some nether dimension or on some alternate world, there is an Earth on which super-heroes are real, living, breathing beings... and now Lois Gresh and Bob Weinberg have shown us how that's possible. Mutants... aliens... scientific geniuses with a penchant for wearing costumes and masks... or just plain Joes who've trained their bodies within an inch of their lives... all are probed, dissected, examined in loving details. To paraphrase an old DC Comics feature: Science says you're wrong if you believe that The Science of Superheroes isn't more fun than a barrel of genetically-altered winged monkeys." —Roy Thomas, writer and editor of X-Men, Fantastic Four, The Incredible Hulk, Superman, Justice League of America, Legion of Superheroes, Star Wars, and many other comic book classics.See all Product Description
Top Customer Reviews
They talk about the Fantastic Four only in the contect of how they got their powers, say they are too silly to even discuss, and move on to re-write the Hulk's origin in a more realistic way. Why not talk about invisibility? What are the links with current technology? There was a guy on Guiness book of world records that can stretch his skin A LOT so why not mention something like that and try to make a link about how you could control it. For example, recent studies with Octopi have shown that they actually walk on the sea floor using two of their tentacles. They fill these with water making them more rigid and thats how they can support some of their weight without the need for a skelatal structure.
I thought the X-men chapter would be good, but instead I got a lecture on Creationism and Evolution. I expected examining Superman's powers in depth and all I got was 10 pages of discussing whether aliens could exist. Not to mention the fact that having Krypton's gravity stronger DOES NOT explain super-strength. He was not born on Krypton, therefore never experienced higher gravity. Being able to withstand a higher gravitational field would NOT be a genetic trait either. Even if he was used to the higher gravitational field, you would eventually become used to the lower one and the super abilities would go away.
Not a very good book in my opinion and the sequal "The Science of Super Villains" looks equally as bad.
After a preface that looks at how superhero comic books came about, an introduction by Dean Koontz entitled "Men of Steel, Feathers of Fury," Gresh and Weinberg devote chapters to the cream of the superhero crop. First up, of course, is Superman, which spends a lot of time examining the math on alien visitors before disproving the idea that the difference in the gravity on Krypton and Earth accounts for Superman's powers (I wonder what they make of the current living solar battery idea). Chapters are then devoted to the Fantastic Four and the Incredible Hulk, Batman, Aquaman and Sub-Mariner, Spider-Man, the Green Lanterns, Ant Man and the Atom, the Flash, the X-Men, science fiction superheroes, and Donald Duck. The last chapter is actually an encomium to Carl Barks, who used science and technology during the golden age of Disney comics.
I picked up this book because I teach Spider-Man in my Popular Culture class and so that chapter alone justified the price of the book for me.Read more ›
The only reason I finished the book was to give it as thorough and un-biased review as possible. The first couple of chapters were quite enjoyable, but the rest of the book just kept me wishing that it was going to get better.
What bothered me the most about this book was the frequent use of the word "impossible". The closed minded approach to the science they addressed is reminiscent of somebody saying the world is flat, that the earth is the center of the universe, that submarines were works of only inventive writers or that the sound barrier can not be broken. The book states that traveling past the speed of light is impossible (the chapter about the Flash), but in a later chapter it goes on to say that time travel is possible. Combine this with the book contradicting itself in the same chapter (the chapter about Spider-Man) and you end up wanting to throttle the authors for their inconsistency.
Then there is the completely irrelevant discussion of creationism in the chapter that was supposed to be about the X-men and evolution. The discussion took up most of the chapter and had nothing to do with mutation.
It is obvious by the end of the book that the authors have done little to zero research on any comic book written since the 80's. Their belief seems to be that Donald Duck was the best comic book ever and that there are no strong super heroines.
Do not waste your time or hard earned money on this book. It has a few (very few) shinning moments of good writing. But they do not offset the obvious dislike of comic books and those who work in the comic book industry.
Most recent customer reviews
Perhaps movie director Kevin Smith said it best when he commented that it was a touch of the impossible that makes superheroes so appealing: "Nobody's built like superheroes are in... Read morePublished on Sept. 29 2003 by Peter Vinton, Jr.
This is an excellent book for those who are not obsessed with superheros but find things like their origins of some interest. Read morePublished on Sept. 10 2003 by James N Simpson
I found this book entertaining and a quick, easy read. Gresh & Weinberg clearly & simply explain what could be complex scientific concepts about most of my favorite... Read morePublished on July 3 2003
...I hoped a lot, too, but didn't get what I had hoped for.
As you can imagine, this book's chosen task is to examine superheroic powers from the standpoint of present-day... Read more
Once again I was grossly disappointed to find bad biology in fiction. IT ISN'T THAT HARD TO DO YOUR RESEARCH! Read morePublished on Jan. 23 2003 by Aaron Spriggs
Doesn't leave a lot of room for imagination. Of course we know a lot of these characters are impossible, that's what's fun. Read morePublished on Dec 27 2002
This was a fun read - but it had several problems. When the man (Dean Koontz in this case) writing the introduction says he doesn't read comics, I began to get worried. Read morePublished on Dec 13 2002 by Ivan A. Wolfe
I enjoyed how this book examined the different superheroes from a scientific perspective and broke down the components of their particular powers, but, c'mon, all of them are... Read morePublished on Dec 11 2002
Almost every chapter tells you why the superhero is impossible. Gresh has no imagination in trying to figure out how future science may explain a superhero. Read morePublished on Dec 1 2002 by Plastic Larry
Look for similar items by category
- Books > Arts & Photography > Drawing
- Books > Arts & Photography > History & Criticism
- Books > Arts & Photography > Instructional & How-To
- Books > Education & Reference > Foreign Language Study & Reference
- Books > Humour & Entertainment > Pop Culture
- Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Philosophy
- Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Social Sciences > Popular Culture
- Books > Science & Math > Biological Sciences
- Books > Science & Math > History & Philosophy > History of Science
- Books > Textbooks > Sciences
- Books > Textbooks > Social Sciences