Top critical review
Very fragile, be ready to go through hoops for warranty support
April 16, 2018
Crappy quality compared to the XBOX 360 version, which I had been using for eight years daily without issue. The left stick started misbehaving after two weeks only and now the controller is totally dead after 1.5 months, the micro-USB connector in the controller keeps disconnecting. Extremely disappointed, won't buy again.
UPDATE: Since the controller failed after 45 days, I couldn't return it to Amazon so I contacted Microsoft. Their initial answer was they would not honor the warranty unless I had an XBox One console registered. It took a bit of back-and-forth with the official Microsoft support but they eventually sent me a new one, which I'm still waiting for (takes about 4 weeks).
UPDATE #2: Two months later I've still not received the replacement, MS claims it got lost in transit (yet tracking shows the product never left) and I'm still waiting for the second replacement. I should have asked my credit card to refund me instead.
UPDATE #: I have finally received the replacement controller, nearly 3 months after the initial warranty claim, after many calls and emails to Microsoft. This was way too much time and energy wasted over a game controller.