I received this maybe 10 minutes ago. I haven't tried connecting to my PC just yet but hoping it works. Will update later for connectivity.
The box looked like it had been opened before. The seal was loosely put on, the box was ripped near one of the folds and the box was overall beaten up. With that said, it doesn't look like it was used for long as it is a white controller and there are no noticeable stains from use. However, there was something on the right thumbstick, noticed quite a bit of dust on the d-pad. When opening the box, you can tell the items inside were previously looked through.
Now you're probably reading this thinking, well if the controller works then what's the big deal? Well, I am about principle. If I had selected the "buy used for: $**" then I'd rate it 5 stars. However, I was under the impression the item I was buying would be factory sealed new.
If you to make sure that it is 100% brand new, I would recommend buying somewhere else other than Amazon. It would be easier to just pick one up at your local Wal-mart, Best Buy, Costco or Target.