I'd be surprised to learn there was any, other, serious competitor for the title of best book on its topic-- a thorough examination of the role of Canadian infantry in World War I. My only reservation is that, as an institutional historian, the author seems a little inclined to the view that the generals knew what they were doing and all the sacrifice was ultimately worth it. The generals didn't-- read Cook's own volume 2 to see how they often abandoned the winning strategies they had so painfully learned in order to yet again throw troops into hopeless situations-- and the consequences of that war: the Russian Bolshevik Revolution, the collapse of the German economy, the rise of Hitler, and the Holocaust certainly do not justify any suggestion that the sacrifice of so many lives was somehow worth it anything. (Also, hints that British PM Lloyd George was a decent man must be balanced against that man's subsequent role in the attempt to partition Turkey., but that's off-topic.) This is an excellent book for learning what the Canadian troops endured in the first part of WWI, and the same praise applies to volume Two's portrayal of the second part of that war-- although, in reading that 2nd volume, the extent of the waste of human life does become nauseating.
What this book delivers is one thing all history books strive to be: Readable. Tim Cook does an excellent job weaving a narrative of Canadians in WW1 that anyone can pick up and read. There is a lot of got information in this book that many will find interesting. I do recommend that you do not let too many younger readers this book as there is some very gory details and harsh language. Great product however!
As Cook makes clear in his introduction, it is not an exhaustive look at Canada during the war. It solely focuses on the Canadian Corps, the army faction that fought; there is nothing about the air corps, navy, home front, and aside from brief mentions of Sam Hughes (minister of militia until 1916), no political details. As the title states, it starts from the Canadian entry into the war alongside the UK in 1914, and ends with the conclusion of the Battle of the Somme in October 1916.
The writing is very clear and straight-forward, and makes great use of quotations from memoirs and letters from soldiers at the front. Cook does a good job to present the horrors that the soldiers had to face, making constant references to the conditions of the trenches, often noting the presence of decaying bodies and human remains scattered about. Naturally, the artillery that characterised the front is also detailed, sometimes preceding the mention of the dead and wounded.
The individual is a constant theme throughout the book. As Cook makes heavy use of soldier's writings, he focuses on them at times; for example, in several instances he will go to lengths detailing how various soldiers acted during a battle, giving the reader a close-up perspective on how it felt. This has a certain effect, amplified as some of these accounts are closed by the somber note that the soldier was later wounded or, quite often, killed later on. Though Cook focuses on the front-line soldiers, he also takes time to detail the officer corps, noting the political aspects that gripped the leadership of the Canadian military to some extent.
Though heavily focused on the battles the Canadians took part in (Second Ypres, St. Julien, Festubert, Somme, to name some), Cook also spends a good amount detailing the other aspects of the war. Chapters explaining the construction and maintenance of the trench system, the rotation of units, their training, and the medical system are just some of the topics covered, giving a more rounded and nuanced impression of life for the soldiers.
I read a lot of military history, and I've come to know that many military historians are BORING writers. Pierre Berton is great, but Tim Cook is maybe better; equally readable while not as rah-rah-rah. This book - and its equally excellent sequel - break the mold. This book is a well-written, brilliantly researched account of a neglected history. Cook doesn't just talk battles, he talks people, lives and society in the trenches. Don't be put off by the length; it's worth your time.
This is the first volume in a two-set history of Canadians in the Great War. This first volume is a tour de force from one of Canada's leading military historians. Based on a wide range of books and academic articles, as well as newly uncovered archival sources (and one marvels at the breadth sources displayed in the footnotes), Cook has produced the most important history ever put into print on the subject of Canadians fighting the Great War.
The author has clearly been studying this subject for years, as the details of battles and the experience of soldiers in combat are among the best in print. From the banality of trench warfare to the titanic battles of Second Ypres, Mount Sorrel, and the Somme, this book presents history as it should be. The words of the soldiers guide us in this tale, but its not just first-hand accounts strung together, as Cook offers deep insight into all levels of war: from the strategic to the operational, from tactics to individuals. In addition, tactics, weapons, and emerging doctrines are meshed with issues of combat motivation, medicine, and the importance of leave. While much of this has been covered by other historians over the years, no one to my mind has ever done it in such detail and with such verve.
Cook has done a great service to this generation that gave so much for their country. I simply can’t wait to read volume II.