Top critical review
10 people found this helpful
Always happy to respond to requests to review....
on September 11, 2012
Mann has asked people to review this book ( via his FB page ) on .CA to help the ratings. Unfortunately I read that "call to arms" but I am one who has read the book and thinks it is very poor. If you want to hear his view of the "war" then fabulous but for most of the population of canada this will be boring. Even if you do think Climate change is a big problem and even if you think humans are totally/partly to blame then you may doze whilst reading about these "conspiracies" blah blah blah.... at the end of the day its all about rigour and I guess this guy tore that page out of the dictionary. The hockey stick is an embarrassment to most professional scientists who once fell for the spin, this book still slavishly tried to defend the flimsy science. If I were the author I would spend less time on Mickey Spillane type scribblings and more time retrospectively visiting assumptions, models and conclusions.