Echo Dot bfdw boutiques-francophones Introducing Fire TV Stick Basic Edition Luxury Beauty home All-New Kindle Oasis Tools

Showing 1-2 of 2 reviews(3 star). See all 37 reviews
on October 31, 2003
This book was a huge inspiration when it first came out about 15 years ago. Sadly they haven't updated it, and nobody has published a better book built on this one's foundation. This has probably been fifteen years of the most rapid change in lutherie.
When I finally got around to building guitars, I hardly cracked open this book, there wasn't anything in it of importance to what I would do. The more modern resources were hugely abundant and mostly free.
The book also hops back and forth between classical and steel string guitars. I would not buy this book to build a classical guitar. There just isn't any of the pertinent modern or old school information between these pages. You have to root around to get the modern stuff, and either a measured drawing, or Masterpiece Guitars would be the best way to get started on the classicals.
The kind of thing you really do to build a good guitar is: There is a lot of interest in Tores classicals, and Hauser. For Hauser you get Jeff Elliot's detailed plan and articles from back issues of American Lutherie. If one was interested in Torres, one could get the great book on the man and his guitars by Jose Romanillos. Romanillos and Elliot have also given the key specifics on the exact features of a tores guitar that make them work, particularly with modern strings. It's actually easier to get going as a beginner or an advanced student, from the magazines and the web. Not true of all craft, but it's true here.
The modern steel string is also not represented in this book, there is a ton of interest in Concert planforms, acoustic electric guitars, jigging manufacture (both amateur and pro), different types of guitar for rhythm vs. say fingerstyle, performance bracing, and so forth. Most informed consumers would make these kinds of choices when buying a guitar, but non of them are covered here as points of departure for a builder. It takes some skill (it seems like everyone is doing it) to make a guitar, but it doesn't require any more skill to start making the right guitar. But you won't get that from this book.
0Comment| 6 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on May 2, 2004
This book was recommended to me by a luthier who had built several quitars. I am in the process of building my first guitar and find the book to be missing many critical details and having several dimmension errors and typo's (All are corrected on Cumpiano's web site). There are some diagrams and pictures, but not nearly enough. The pictures that are there are very dark, black and white pics that are hard to see clearly. Some of the techniques are very out of date and I have found much better material on the web. I have found much simpler construction methods from a manual for a guitar kit from an Ohio luthier supply company that I downloaded for free. I would recommend this book only for those interested in the history of guitar making or would like an additional reference. THIS IS NOT A GOOD STEP BY STEP CONSTRUCTION MANUAL FOR CONSTRUCTING A GUITAR.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse